Showing posts with label Alexander. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alexander. Show all posts

9.04.2008

Order/Disorder Part 2: The Absence of Right

In the absence of right, loneliness and desperation reign. For when Right has dimmed, so too does mankind—inward looking for answers, he bellows into an empty space, spending his time breathing and avoiding hunger. He hopes to distill the echoes inside of his private chamber to only those of his own voice from the voices of those who, by their earthly wherewithal alone, have managed to shout into it as well. When right eludes, the institutions that dominate every relationship between human beings become like a God. However, they are not God—they are terrestrial, and thus temporary. Left with no purpose or manner of pursuing the good, a man has only his ability to breathe. He has his possessions, which will leave. He has his friends, who will die. And he has a world to inhabit that only seeks to inspire him to believe, that the way things are now are the way they should be. That this world is right. But it cannot be. And when it ends, another will replace it, with much the same method of convincing the man of his rightness. And so he is not righteous, but compliant. Not productive, but replicable and able to replicate. He does not progress, but instead just accepts.

The above describes both the Hellenistic world in which I live, as well as the transition into the Hellenistic period that Greece experienced after Alexander. Following the dominance of Macedonian Greeks Phillip II and Alexander the Great, the city state as a political form of any relevance died away. Nothing took its place, per se—instead, it was rendered impotent by the dynastic power centers that emerged when Alexander’s generals carved up the territory that he and his father had brought under their control. Although still in existence, true self-determination through democratic means withered. Subsequently, the feeling that men could work together to make the good come alive in their earthly lives fell away. The mood of the Hellenistic world was uncertain and unstable—kingdoms changed hands, new leaders emerged and fell, and the polis, constantly reconstituted, failed to provide any longer the backbone of society. Without that avenue by which one could build a world based on the Right, depression grew rampant. At least it does in me as I consider the end of the Greek world I’ve studied and the non-system that came to replace it. Prudence was pointless. The struggle for survival became top priority, and the individuals who, in former times, would have sent a message that resonated, faced marginalization in a world not interested in listening.

A man, although once possessing free will, learns to accept. Often by the time he grows to adulthood he has forgotten entirely that he had humanity at all. But the shouts in the private space now sound like his own voice, and he follows them, still believing himself to be self-propelled. A lucky few have maintained their capacity for discernment, though. The voices are torturous, to be sure, but clearly not from him. It’s a life of agony, and sometimes self-deceit. He lives a life not of searching, but of constantly re-finding, and, having replenished himself from the filtered faucet can see the right and move it forward, going along with it. But to pursue the right is not to serve an institution that serves itself.

Integrity is labeled egoism by those who believe the institution to be right, and forgetting one’s place. Best to relinquish humanity, and utilize the tools of reason and eros, not for their intended purpose, the pursuit of right, but to application for the sake of the institution, the dynasty, and for those whose fathers constructed it and must maintain it now. The creator still uses rhetoric and craftsmanship. However, he employs them for theatricality, to exercise power because he can, or to glorify himself or the powers which already are. Sensing their unimportance, they desperately seek to fabricate it and soothe their fluid non-selves.

Survival and “excellence” was available via relationships with the centers of power. As I noted in my post on rhetoric, the “discovery” of the power of rhetoric to people like Plato and Isocrates was a mixed bag, relative to other sophists of the period. Should these tools be used for personal gain? As a delivery system and a mechanism for control? Or should they be used to pursue the right and to make it happen in the world? The former seems to have won out…rhetoric, and the underlying idea of logos was co-opted by the power centers, and subjugated to the purely functional. Art was self-glorifying, and although people like Snell posit that this is a discovery of the self and the individual, I think it’s a distancing. It’s communicating a message for an intended purpose, and ultimately for a closed system…not for the sake of moving thought forward on a larger, and ultimately unknowable, trajectory. The same reason I find it repugnant in this period is the same reason I, and most for that matter, find marketing and advertising repulsive nowadays—it’s a pursuit with definite boundaries, and end which without even realizing it is to serve and support those who hold power and the institutions which support them.

The stability and the fantasy of order emerge, and enticing with force and coercion, reign beyond all else. Working to end change, to ensure stability, are mankind’s labors, and he works to dull and kill himself. In such a world, survival is not valuable.

Supporting those institutions is to deny that which is truly human, by closing off the potential of the human mind and the capacity it has for creative thought and the creation of the new. Why is it better to live than to die? As far as I’m concerned, existence for the sake of perpetuating existence is pointless and stupid. The purpose is temporary, and the pursuit will likely change tomorrow, and set itself up with the same trappings as the purpose before it.

But change persists, and despite the institution’s best efforts it crumbles. The elites, the sycophants of the top tiers have acquired their position through replication, not production. They’ve created a status that reinforces their place, favoring good taste over the Right and the good. But they have declared the taste they have defined to be good, and spend their days becoming experts in proclaiming its importance, and indexing and categorizing it for quick reference, easing transmission of their impotent preference, and thus their own importance.

Here, I had Callimachus the poet in mind. He was a librarian at Alexandria, and claimed to “hate all things common.” I’m back and forth with him…although I believe I know what he meant by saying that (in a sense, decrying the very type of pursuit and belief that I’ve been criticizing so far in this piece), his pursuit seems more for the purpose of doing it just because he can, and not because it was good or right. Then again, by making as almost a requirement the intense study of literature and words, and favoring concise and well structured poetry, perhaps he was in fact doing precisely that which I have trouble seeing during this period…rising above the muck, breaking through the traditional methods of communication and creating an unadorned message. But to save it just for the learned...there’s something I find repelling in that. What’s the point of making art, if it’s for art itself and not for the levels to which it can elevate human life, and make it all more liveable? The jury will have to stay out on Callimachus for now. As for the library at Alexandria, their primary achievement was the generation of cataloguing tools, without which many of the works now seen as the paragons of the Classical world would be lost to us. However, my point here is that replicating and reconstituting past work, saving it and storing it up, seems not only elitist, but uninspired. Better to rest on the laurels of the past?

When the structure that propped up the elites begins to bend and crack, they ensure their position in a newly constituted house by convincing the new owner of their use to him. That is if they haven’t died in the interim, for another, already forgotten kingdom.

I had Archimedes in mind here. Truly, one of the most gifted mathematical minds whose work is on record and noted. Many of his most noted achievements, though, were to benefit his sponsor, the king of Syracuse. The discovery of measuring volume through water displacement? Formulated in order to tell, through the calculation of density, if the king’s crown was truly made of gold. The Archimedes screw? Used to pump bilge water out of the king’s galleys, the largest ships the world had every seen. Granted, the mathematics that Archimedes formulated came remarkably close to the science that Newton would one day conceive of and which we now call calculus. And Archimedes considered his greatest achievement not the above mentioned engineering advances, but the proof that the surface area and volume of a cylinder were 2/3 that of a sphere of the same proportions. But what happened to Archimedes? In a moment of unbelievable symbolism, he was ignobly killed by a random Roman soldier when the king of Syracuse was conquered.

For those with little to offer, but resources to survive, the practice is different. They’re self-sufficient in that which supports them, and align with ease to each new wave with the power of their anonymity. They too, though, have relinquished their humanity, pursuing survival without questioning why it was crucial to survive at all. But having lost their free will, and not seeing an order in the world around them to which they can look, and believing themselves pushed and incapable of pushing, they look to the stars, or inside. Above what forces are taking me, and where do I go now? Who am I? And what role should I play? The questions are the same when the individual looks to his own feet, where he believes he must find a new method to accept, and learns to get along and stop steering entirely.

During the Hellenistic period, Sumerian astrology came into widespread practice. I think that the belief in astrology comes as a result of a psychological reaction to one’s circumstances in life or to the state of the world. It provides a comfort, a way to turn off and relinquish control and responsibility. As for the internal pursuit…well, I thought I’d be really into the philosophy of this era. The Cynics, the Stoics, the Epicureans…I though that kind of thinking would be very attractive and insightful. But it’s just kind of sad. It’s a practice of acceptance. Of getting along, and avoiding engagement in the world. Introspection is critical in human life, but this kind of introspection just reads, to me, like a big giving up. On the other hand, much of the Cynic philosophy was learning how to “distill”, as I mentioned above—defacing the coinage, as Zeno put it. Thus I think the philosophy of the period had a lot to offer, but didn’t really push anything forward. They suggested a way of life that would make existence tolerable, but without committing to any real meaning. Kind of like postmodernism…

In the absence of right, man is not man. He has sunk to the bottom of a stagnant lake, or drags across the sand and learns to appreciate it. He is complicit in this, and will remain so forever. He will rot and die, with only particles left, not ever sensing what his role could have been in building the tower to the sky, and contributing to the eternal motion of that which is good.

To serve the institution that reigns is to be the institution, not oneself. I haven’t even mentioned Menander and New Comedy…the first situational comedy. It’s all rags to riches stuff, fluff entertainment. No catharsis, only resolution to the story. I’ll miss tragedy. I wrote the un-italicized stuff first, and filled in with some facts and what I’ve been thinking with the italicized text. Thank you for humoring me on this—it hasn’t been a failure on my part per se, but I always work hard to internalize whatever I’m studying in the project, and it can come out in a billion different ways. Just look at the Aristotle post. Additionally, although I suggested that I’d write something big on the Greeks, I think I’m going to take on the whole ancient Mediterranean in that…at this point in Greek history where I leave off in this post, the Romans have already fought the Punic wars, and are about to really take off as an Empire, soon after the Hellenistic period ends (when the Cleopatra and the Ptolemaic dynasty, the last of the Alexandrian kingdoms, falls to Augustus). With so much overlap, it’s better to take it in all at once, and make room for the next revolution in thinking…early Christianity. Etruscans and Early Romans next time.