Showing posts with label Stoics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Stoics. Show all posts

11.05.2009

The Historical Jesus-Parables as Data Point



I am distressed to learn that history has yet again only further deepened my sense of general meaninglessness and disappointment. How is it that, after months of studying the Historical Jesus, his Jewish antecedents, and technological and scholarly discussion on the intent of his words that I can feel less inspired by the story of Jesus than almost anything else I've studied. Blasphemous, I know, and I'm sure my mom's feelings will again be crushed upon learning that I can't muster even a scintilla of inspiration or even panacea from knowing more about Jesus. I'm sure that's the general trend among things when one asks too many question, digs too deep—stripping away the golds flakes of mystique to reveal a leaden form. What solutions do we, the faithless, have, in the end? I guess I can't yet accept that at least some openness to a sense of truth will someday result in some kind of good feeling.

So here I am, yet again, discussing the particularities in stone cold form those ideas and stories that people once held and still hold as sacred. Just another naked emperor. The region in which Jesus was purported to have lived, Galilea, was the backwoods region of a kingdom called Judea (still unbelievable to me, and perhaps this is something I should work on, that a region a third the size of my state could manage such cultural diversity...to consider later, I suppose). Judea had undergone the influence of Hellenic culture for centuries, beginning with the carving up of Alexander's conquered territory into separate kingdoms. After significant fighting, Judea had come under Seleucid rule, which was later overthrown by the Maccabee clan (enter the Chanukkah tradition, by the way). The Maccabees founded the Hasmonean dynasty, who ruled the Kingdom of Judea for over a century, when a series of internal conflicts eventually led to the establishment of the Herodian dynasty, which would become the client government of the nascent Romen Empire via its chosen king, the half Jewish Herod. Herod was jealous, suspicious, and murdererous. However, he also constructed Caesaria, which would become a bustling and successful port city, and a new temple, ruled over by the priests, or levites, of a sect of Judaism called the Sadducees. Judea had a greater population than any other Roman province during Herod's rule, and enjoyed a very cosmopolitan and mixed population in the cities.

The Sadducees were, by Jewish law, not only the religious elite but also law givers. They collaborated closely with Herod and his Roman patrons, most notably among them Mark Anthony, in maintaining order throughout Judea. However, this was more difficult than it simply seemed. For centuries the Jews had rejected foreign domination. They conflated as a part of their religious worldview their governance, their culture, and the religion that dictated the precepts, rituals, and practices of that culture. The Maccabees exemplify the tradition of armed conflict against foreign occupiers and rules, following the attempt by the Seleucid leadership to Hellenize Judea by outlawing temple rituals, circumcision, etc. This tension between Hellenism and Judaism remained markedly present strain in the thinking of the community for centuries to follow. A notable aspect of this strain, the Maccabees and their followers had targeted the Hellenes, but had additionally targeted their Jewish collaborators. Those that complied with demands to Hellenize were punished with death. Flash forward and one can see why a certain antagonism existed within Judaism, especially towards the priestly class intent on payoffs and political power through their position as temple leadership.

This Judaism existed under Roman dominance, fractured itself by decades of civil war, where we meet Julius Caesar, Pompey, Augustus, Brutus, and Mark Antony. The whole Mediterranean was in flux, where people reached out for strategic political allegiances for their very survival, seeking to protect themselves and the institutions that gave them power. These centers of power were themselves legitimized by declared divine mandate, and the complicity of soothsayers and priests.

Enter into this world Jesus of Nazareth, son of Joseph. There is no evidence whatsoever to suggest he was born in Bethlehem or lived with his family in exile, nor is there any evidence of the purported edicts that would have made his family go to either Bethlehem or leave Galilea. He was a tradesman, like his father. Here begins centuries of storytelling and work to recreate the life of Jesus, his ministry, his beliefs, and his death. My next post will dig in greater detail into the myth that the early Christian church created around the actual man, to both explain the failure that Jesus's death before the coming of God represented (called, in scholarly circles, the criterion of dissimilarity, or embarrassment, that makes more valid certain aspects of the Jesus story), and influence of the period in which which the gospels were written. I change course now, from historical narrative to that which most interests me and is most relevant to this project.

Although the storyline illuminates these texts with regards to how religions form and circumstances that inform them, this project is first and foremost a chronicle of the project. So what, if anything, does this have to do with it? A tough question, even as it seems to me. This project matters because it's about sources and data. However, as any social scientist or historian working with primary sources will tell you, data is most of all a function of strength and validity of the source material. Distinguishing the sayings and intent of Jesus and the writings of those whose works would become the New Testament matters because of the context, and subsequently the intent of the work. The writers of the New Testament produced their texts decades after Jesus death, during the height of the first Jewish revolt and the first examples of the systematic persecution of Christians under the Roman Empire. That being said, even distinguishing Jesus work from his followers, most notably the work of Paul, opens Jesus' sayings open to an interpretation which, on one side, he demonstrates a greater influence on one side and on the other, an entirely different school.

At the center of this debate in studies of the historical Jesus is what is called eschatology, apocalypticism, and millenarieanism. But how does one define any of these terms? Scholars debate this matter presently, especially those who believe Jesus never intended his words to mean that the cosmos or history itself would end, but instead think he meant to create a Kingdom of God brought about by ideas, and self-exploration and those who believe he actually wanted to suggest the coming of a power great than the Roman Empire itself. Such a coming would bring about a great social upheaval, bringing justice and order for the people who were oppressed and downtrodden that the world as one knew it at the time would be totally unrecognizable, if even existant in the physical sense.

A quick note. Eschatology means the end of history as we know it. Human experience will cease under its present precepts and will exist under its present precepts and will exist under an illuminative constraint brought about by the arrival of God or his vicerroy (in this case Jesus). Apocalypse, or apocalyptic, is the physical manifestation of this eschatological vision—the signs, the events, and most of all the coming of a messiah or king that promises a new order. Millenarianism is simply the end of an earthly period, with the expectation of a new one's beginning.

Believe it or not, Nobel Prize winner Albert Schweizer is one of the big names in this field, as are Strauss, Kant, Norman Perrin, and Jon Dominic Crossan, Marcus Borg, and myriad others. I've read Borg and Crossan, and their views diverge. For me, and my intent, their varied description have a great impact on my own sense of what could have influenced Jesus' thinking.

After all, Judea was a very Hellenicized region, despite the best attempts of the Jewish leadership to keep it out. Cynic, Stoic, and Epicurean teachers would have traveled as itinerant teachers, speaking in Koine Green and describing the world view of their school. If Jesus actually believed a coming of God was near, that he was the Messiah, then I think his sources were more Judaic in origin. The Essenes, an ascetic sect of Judaism that had a major problem with the priestly classes of Judaism, would have certainly had an influence on this. John the Baptist comes to mind in this regard.

On the other hand, did Jesus want to bring about a kingdom of men, ruled by a new ethic? This viewpoint was especially during the age of liberalism. Kant, especially, stands out. Within this paradigm, Jesus actually wished to convey that the kingdom of God could happen by our actions—he describes, in this sense, not an apocalyptic eschatology but a prophetic eschatology. Some say this misconstrues the history. In our life and times is seems to have a greater resonance. Instead of the actual son of God, Jesus is a sage, a learned person, taking something from cynicism, stoicisim, even platonism. These philosophies converge to create a kingdom of ethic that is lived, and not necessarily created by a government.

So which is it? Is he the true king of the Jews, the bringer of a new kingdom? Did he miscalculate, and is that miscalculation conjured up by those who later chronologized his life by suggesting a new interpretation and a second coming?

I believe that Jesus was a philosophical and ethical leader, who was informed by the abundance of Hellenic teachers and the need that the historical and cultural context created for turning inward, when outward action could only fail. Whether in the course of his teaching he became convinced of his own holiness, I don't know. I take the middle ground, and consider the sayings of Jesus as a separate data point, distinct from the New Testament and the gospels that narrate his life. He was a man with thorough knowledge of the limits of the hierarchy to bring about change and knew that change would happen only by personal commitment to a new morality.

2.04.2009

Schools of Thought in Rome, and the Intellectual World of Cicero

I've recently wrapped up an examination of Cicero, approaching him from the context of the vast array of beliefs and philosophies that thrived throughout Roman territory and the Mediterranean generally.  This diversity of thought prevailed for centuries before Cicero, and would continue for centuries after him.  What strikes me as peculiar and challenging as I try to understand the opportunities for contemplation available to Romans is the lack of any real mainstream or state sponsored religion.  As long as the populace respected state sponsored holidays, it seems like people could worship pretty much whomever or whatever they wanted. 

Gods like Jupiter and Minerva are among many forces in the world unseen that can have an impact on our lives.  Ancestral worship, carried over from the Etruscans, remained a major influence in people's lives, as has been noted in my first post about Roman art.  Superstitions used for good luck or for curative purposes, originating from God-knows-where, abounded.  Foreign influences that entered the Roman realm as its borders expanded also paved the way for foreign religions, and the activity of priests that guarded the associated rites and rituals.  Worship of Ra and other Egyptian deities came into vogue in Rome even before the inclusion of Egypt into the Roman empire after the Battle of Actium, and interest in Egyptian culture and religion positively exploded among the upper classes in the century that followed.  Groups dedicated to Mithras, from Babylon and Persia, as well as Sumerian astrology were not uncommon among even the most mainstream Romans.  An abundance of figures from the Greek pantheon had their own worshippers, centered around temples and oracles dedicated to that god alone. Major changes were afoot in Judaism, but it was Herod, the King of Judea and a servant to Rome, who rebuilt the temple, and by the turn of the millennium we begin to see the growth of Rabbinic Judaism, gnosticism, and that little subsect of Jews known much later on as Christians.

Of greatest interest to me is the persistence of philosophical schools throughout the Roman empire, with their roots as far back as the Academy in Athens and enjoying widespread popularity across the Mediterranean.  When understood in the context of the diversity of options for religious devotion, these competing schools of thought (literally) amaze me.  The teachings of men like Epicurus, Zeno, and Diogenes boggle my mind, not necessarily because of their insights, but because their lessons and views provided the basis for centuries old traditions of teachers and scholars that propagated and added to the original thinkers' work.  I am stunned and in awe watching a body of data become a discourse, to see it transmit and grow independent of politics or geography.

This was the intellectual and contemplative world of Rome--for the elite, almost limitless availability to a variety of world views and teachings.  Greek methods of teaching persisted, becoming all the more prevalent once Rome defeats Greece.  Members of the Roman upper class brought literate and well-educated Greeks (often enslaved) to educate their children.  Wandering sophists gave lessons in math, philosophy, and rhetoric, much as they did in the Greece of Aristotle.  Societies of men devoted to cynicism, stoicism, and epicureanism (among many others), set up schools in all the major cities to inculcate interested students in their system of thought.  Much like the syncretism of Roman art, philosophy also enjoyed an eclectic heyday under the Roman empire, wherein one chose that which suited him best.

Cicero, for his part, chose Academic skepticism.  First advanced by Pyrrho, a former soldier in Alexander's army, and later promoted by Pyrrho's disciple Timon, does not receive a good review from my friend Mr. Bertrand Russell:  "Scepticism," he writes in The History of Western Philosophy, "was a lazy man's consolation, since it showed the ignorant to be as wise as the reputed men of learning" (pg. 234, see links on the right for copyright and citation info on my edition).  In my mind, however, skepticism seems the most obvious heir apparent to thinkers like Isocrates and Plato, who questioned through dialectical reasoning the very premise of deductive reasoning itself.  In fact, for many years after the death of Aristotle, the Academy remained the center of Academic skeptical thought.  Cicero, for his part, believes as Plato did: that although one can be convinced of the greater probability of one argument over another, he will never achieve absolute certainty of the truth.  Although it doesn't seem that he ever makes a metaphysical leap as Plato does from this spot, causing him to question sensory experience in general or considering a metaphysical sphere beyond rational thought, he channels this assumption into some very cunning political writing.  As such, his thinking is although remarkably similar to Aristotle's in terms of the discussion of a politician/philosopher duality and the way by which one creates a great city and state.  It's practical, and, well, skeptical of everyone's motives, but still seems to express real optimism by remaining firmly planted in this sphere (unlike Plato).  His greatest concern is to translate the thinking of Plato, Aristotle, and others into his time and the circumstances of Rome itself, and trying to make sense of it in a way that would be useful to building a great state.  This is a stellar example of the peculiar creativity of Roman syncretism.

Well, now that I've finally got all that philosophy stuff out of me, I can begin to add some new writings to the list.  The problem with many of the aforementioned schools of thought is that few primary sources exist.  Therefore, I will satisfy myself with adding Diogenes Laertius's Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, which for many centuries has been the go-to text for hearing accounts of the lives and teachings of guys like Zeno (stoicism), Epicurus (epicureanism), and Diogenes (a different Diogenes--this one helped to found cynicism).  In addition, I'll be adding a couple of other writers to the list along with Cicero and his Laws, specifically essays by Seneca the Younger (a stoic philosopher and tutor to Nero), and Emperor Marcus Aurelius's Meditations (Marcus Aurelius was also very scholarly and a stoic, and reigned at what is likely the height of Roman power).  Next up, literature in the age of Augustus, Roman novel writing, my last post on art, and Plotinus (The founder of neo-platonism and the last great philosopher of antiquity).  Then on to the Christians...

9.04.2008

Order/Disorder Part 2: The Absence of Right

In the absence of right, loneliness and desperation reign. For when Right has dimmed, so too does mankind—inward looking for answers, he bellows into an empty space, spending his time breathing and avoiding hunger. He hopes to distill the echoes inside of his private chamber to only those of his own voice from the voices of those who, by their earthly wherewithal alone, have managed to shout into it as well. When right eludes, the institutions that dominate every relationship between human beings become like a God. However, they are not God—they are terrestrial, and thus temporary. Left with no purpose or manner of pursuing the good, a man has only his ability to breathe. He has his possessions, which will leave. He has his friends, who will die. And he has a world to inhabit that only seeks to inspire him to believe, that the way things are now are the way they should be. That this world is right. But it cannot be. And when it ends, another will replace it, with much the same method of convincing the man of his rightness. And so he is not righteous, but compliant. Not productive, but replicable and able to replicate. He does not progress, but instead just accepts.

The above describes both the Hellenistic world in which I live, as well as the transition into the Hellenistic period that Greece experienced after Alexander. Following the dominance of Macedonian Greeks Phillip II and Alexander the Great, the city state as a political form of any relevance died away. Nothing took its place, per se—instead, it was rendered impotent by the dynastic power centers that emerged when Alexander’s generals carved up the territory that he and his father had brought under their control. Although still in existence, true self-determination through democratic means withered. Subsequently, the feeling that men could work together to make the good come alive in their earthly lives fell away. The mood of the Hellenistic world was uncertain and unstable—kingdoms changed hands, new leaders emerged and fell, and the polis, constantly reconstituted, failed to provide any longer the backbone of society. Without that avenue by which one could build a world based on the Right, depression grew rampant. At least it does in me as I consider the end of the Greek world I’ve studied and the non-system that came to replace it. Prudence was pointless. The struggle for survival became top priority, and the individuals who, in former times, would have sent a message that resonated, faced marginalization in a world not interested in listening.

A man, although once possessing free will, learns to accept. Often by the time he grows to adulthood he has forgotten entirely that he had humanity at all. But the shouts in the private space now sound like his own voice, and he follows them, still believing himself to be self-propelled. A lucky few have maintained their capacity for discernment, though. The voices are torturous, to be sure, but clearly not from him. It’s a life of agony, and sometimes self-deceit. He lives a life not of searching, but of constantly re-finding, and, having replenished himself from the filtered faucet can see the right and move it forward, going along with it. But to pursue the right is not to serve an institution that serves itself.

Integrity is labeled egoism by those who believe the institution to be right, and forgetting one’s place. Best to relinquish humanity, and utilize the tools of reason and eros, not for their intended purpose, the pursuit of right, but to application for the sake of the institution, the dynasty, and for those whose fathers constructed it and must maintain it now. The creator still uses rhetoric and craftsmanship. However, he employs them for theatricality, to exercise power because he can, or to glorify himself or the powers which already are. Sensing their unimportance, they desperately seek to fabricate it and soothe their fluid non-selves.

Survival and “excellence” was available via relationships with the centers of power. As I noted in my post on rhetoric, the “discovery” of the power of rhetoric to people like Plato and Isocrates was a mixed bag, relative to other sophists of the period. Should these tools be used for personal gain? As a delivery system and a mechanism for control? Or should they be used to pursue the right and to make it happen in the world? The former seems to have won out…rhetoric, and the underlying idea of logos was co-opted by the power centers, and subjugated to the purely functional. Art was self-glorifying, and although people like Snell posit that this is a discovery of the self and the individual, I think it’s a distancing. It’s communicating a message for an intended purpose, and ultimately for a closed system…not for the sake of moving thought forward on a larger, and ultimately unknowable, trajectory. The same reason I find it repugnant in this period is the same reason I, and most for that matter, find marketing and advertising repulsive nowadays—it’s a pursuit with definite boundaries, and end which without even realizing it is to serve and support those who hold power and the institutions which support them.

The stability and the fantasy of order emerge, and enticing with force and coercion, reign beyond all else. Working to end change, to ensure stability, are mankind’s labors, and he works to dull and kill himself. In such a world, survival is not valuable.

Supporting those institutions is to deny that which is truly human, by closing off the potential of the human mind and the capacity it has for creative thought and the creation of the new. Why is it better to live than to die? As far as I’m concerned, existence for the sake of perpetuating existence is pointless and stupid. The purpose is temporary, and the pursuit will likely change tomorrow, and set itself up with the same trappings as the purpose before it.

But change persists, and despite the institution’s best efforts it crumbles. The elites, the sycophants of the top tiers have acquired their position through replication, not production. They’ve created a status that reinforces their place, favoring good taste over the Right and the good. But they have declared the taste they have defined to be good, and spend their days becoming experts in proclaiming its importance, and indexing and categorizing it for quick reference, easing transmission of their impotent preference, and thus their own importance.

Here, I had Callimachus the poet in mind. He was a librarian at Alexandria, and claimed to “hate all things common.” I’m back and forth with him…although I believe I know what he meant by saying that (in a sense, decrying the very type of pursuit and belief that I’ve been criticizing so far in this piece), his pursuit seems more for the purpose of doing it just because he can, and not because it was good or right. Then again, by making as almost a requirement the intense study of literature and words, and favoring concise and well structured poetry, perhaps he was in fact doing precisely that which I have trouble seeing during this period…rising above the muck, breaking through the traditional methods of communication and creating an unadorned message. But to save it just for the learned...there’s something I find repelling in that. What’s the point of making art, if it’s for art itself and not for the levels to which it can elevate human life, and make it all more liveable? The jury will have to stay out on Callimachus for now. As for the library at Alexandria, their primary achievement was the generation of cataloguing tools, without which many of the works now seen as the paragons of the Classical world would be lost to us. However, my point here is that replicating and reconstituting past work, saving it and storing it up, seems not only elitist, but uninspired. Better to rest on the laurels of the past?

When the structure that propped up the elites begins to bend and crack, they ensure their position in a newly constituted house by convincing the new owner of their use to him. That is if they haven’t died in the interim, for another, already forgotten kingdom.

I had Archimedes in mind here. Truly, one of the most gifted mathematical minds whose work is on record and noted. Many of his most noted achievements, though, were to benefit his sponsor, the king of Syracuse. The discovery of measuring volume through water displacement? Formulated in order to tell, through the calculation of density, if the king’s crown was truly made of gold. The Archimedes screw? Used to pump bilge water out of the king’s galleys, the largest ships the world had every seen. Granted, the mathematics that Archimedes formulated came remarkably close to the science that Newton would one day conceive of and which we now call calculus. And Archimedes considered his greatest achievement not the above mentioned engineering advances, but the proof that the surface area and volume of a cylinder were 2/3 that of a sphere of the same proportions. But what happened to Archimedes? In a moment of unbelievable symbolism, he was ignobly killed by a random Roman soldier when the king of Syracuse was conquered.

For those with little to offer, but resources to survive, the practice is different. They’re self-sufficient in that which supports them, and align with ease to each new wave with the power of their anonymity. They too, though, have relinquished their humanity, pursuing survival without questioning why it was crucial to survive at all. But having lost their free will, and not seeing an order in the world around them to which they can look, and believing themselves pushed and incapable of pushing, they look to the stars, or inside. Above what forces are taking me, and where do I go now? Who am I? And what role should I play? The questions are the same when the individual looks to his own feet, where he believes he must find a new method to accept, and learns to get along and stop steering entirely.

During the Hellenistic period, Sumerian astrology came into widespread practice. I think that the belief in astrology comes as a result of a psychological reaction to one’s circumstances in life or to the state of the world. It provides a comfort, a way to turn off and relinquish control and responsibility. As for the internal pursuit…well, I thought I’d be really into the philosophy of this era. The Cynics, the Stoics, the Epicureans…I though that kind of thinking would be very attractive and insightful. But it’s just kind of sad. It’s a practice of acceptance. Of getting along, and avoiding engagement in the world. Introspection is critical in human life, but this kind of introspection just reads, to me, like a big giving up. On the other hand, much of the Cynic philosophy was learning how to “distill”, as I mentioned above—defacing the coinage, as Zeno put it. Thus I think the philosophy of the period had a lot to offer, but didn’t really push anything forward. They suggested a way of life that would make existence tolerable, but without committing to any real meaning. Kind of like postmodernism…

In the absence of right, man is not man. He has sunk to the bottom of a stagnant lake, or drags across the sand and learns to appreciate it. He is complicit in this, and will remain so forever. He will rot and die, with only particles left, not ever sensing what his role could have been in building the tower to the sky, and contributing to the eternal motion of that which is good.

To serve the institution that reigns is to be the institution, not oneself. I haven’t even mentioned Menander and New Comedy…the first situational comedy. It’s all rags to riches stuff, fluff entertainment. No catharsis, only resolution to the story. I’ll miss tragedy. I wrote the un-italicized stuff first, and filled in with some facts and what I’ve been thinking with the italicized text. Thank you for humoring me on this—it hasn’t been a failure on my part per se, but I always work hard to internalize whatever I’m studying in the project, and it can come out in a billion different ways. Just look at the Aristotle post. Additionally, although I suggested that I’d write something big on the Greeks, I think I’m going to take on the whole ancient Mediterranean in that…at this point in Greek history where I leave off in this post, the Romans have already fought the Punic wars, and are about to really take off as an Empire, soon after the Hellenistic period ends (when the Cleopatra and the Ptolemaic dynasty, the last of the Alexandrian kingdoms, falls to Augustus). With so much overlap, it’s better to take it in all at once, and make room for the next revolution in thinking…early Christianity. Etruscans and Early Romans next time.