A few days ago, I saw the largest public mental health hospital in Argentina, which serves over a thousand inpatients from areas throughout the autonomous federal district of Buenos Aires. The building simultaneously looked as if it could crumble at any time and stand for another hundred years. A contradiction, maybe, but I got the sense that building had looked as it it was about to crumble for decades. What appeared to me as dilapidated would probably remain so--a great work of public financing, concrete and peeling paint, it seemed like a cross between an ancient English prison or public school and almost all the buildings I ever saw in Cuba. There was nothing beautiful or quaint about that place. It frightened me to approach it, frightened me to even look at it. It engaged me most of all in what it represented.
Nothing about the mental hospital indicated anything to me that suggested rehabilitation or care. I only saw something morose, neglected--marginalized. Certainly someone like myself, unfortunately well-versed in Foucault and postmodernism, needed no crumbling wall to assist in my own taught method of deconstruction. The place sits in the margins of the city, among warehouses and streets lined with prostitutes and transvestites. It wasn't inclined to therapy, certainly not treatment. It physically stood as a sign of power, of the state and a nation declaring what they wanted to become, in this case declaring what they would not have or accept.
So too, did I read the history of the Jews as they lived through the time when both myth and scholarship suppose Jesus to have lived, and bloody decades of revolt and open revolution that followed. The Jews had struggled under foreign kings for centuries, and struggled with all degrees of their leadership's usurpation by interlopers--the Babylonians, the Seleucids, the Hasmonians, the Romans. The priestly class would comply or collude, or not, or some degree in between. Revolts of all kinds, most famously under the Maccabees, challenged the kingdom that ruled the Jews, in an attempt to create the kingdom prescribed by their religion, and that promised to them by God to which their myths had declared them entitled. Those same traditions declared that they should fight to assure that their kingdom would remain theirs, ruled according to the order that God's laws declared.
I am certain that this synopsis does not properly give due to the history of the Jews. I now write for the second time on the Jews with this post, and I know enough to know one could do a project like the one to which I have applied myself on their story and beliefs alone. Maybe later. Nonetheless, I do no intend here to give a thorough treatment of the Jews and their history. Only to know enough so that I might properly situate the items I would put on my list, those which continue to influence today's world--the Gospels, and the New Testament written to promote the church of new religion of St. Paul and St. Peter.
The story of the Historical Jesus, and the story of the early church and the documents it would produce to me speak almost entirely of power. Jesus's followers would reread Jewish traditional text in a manner that would ultimately become a religion of its own. For a time, though, when the Jewish kingdom fell into chaos and uncertainty over its own future, what would become Christianity would almost become the future of Judaism itself.
Regardless, though, of what may have happened, Christianity departed from all other religions. However, it maintained certain similarities, directly or not, to Greek and Roman schools of thought like Stoicism and Platonism--its revolutionary change lied in its relationship with and departure from societal order, control and governance of the day. The kingdom on earth paled in its majesty to the new idea of a Kingdom of God, not achieved here on earth but acting as a model, and those who sought to promote it here in this deceptive earthly world would surely live well in a higher one encountered only after death, reigned over by the creator himself, the son he sent to communicate its existence, and the spirit within all of us to receive that message.
This understanding would require a new set of myths, though, and a new foundation from which this worldview would grow. Thus the gospels, altogether different from the Jesus that really existed. I will write again on the Historical Jesus and the world in which he lived, and again on the gospels and Paul and Peter's church. I have yet to face something so difficult to wrap my head around as the Historical Jesus and the rise of the Christian church.
Showing posts with label Jews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jews. Show all posts
10.09.2009
6.30.2007
Unfortunately Literary Notes on the Old Testament
And so things which in the grandest schemes matter so little garner over-the-top importance. My superficial study and cursory notes on the Hebrews and the Old Testament struggle to coalesce into words. But the impact of the book from this otherwise insignificant tribe, as well as their presence in and documentation of the Ancient World, deserves at least the attention I’ve given it. But the Hebrews were just another tribe, and the Old Testament is a multi-layered text of many authors. Several blogs discuss these issues—one asks if the Old Testament is only a text, the other posits an argument against the Bible having several authors. However I studied this material primarily through reading Don’t Know Much About the Bible and listening to Elizabeth Vandiver’s lectures in Great Authors of the Western Literary Tradition. The discussion in these texts of the Pentateuch, or first five books of the Old Testament, and the Deuteronomistic History (the books of Joshua through Esther) presents the Old Testament as a work of literature through valuable analyses that I discuss here.
The outlooks I present deconstruct the text of the Old Testament; the first outlook, by assigning authorship, the second, by identifying the commitment and values of the author. The Pentateuch brings together the narratives and oral traditions that chronicle the tribe’s origins and ancestry. Some text, such as that of the creation, reads like a myth. Similarities in story and symbolism between this truly mythological account and those of other neighboring cultures implies the development of mythology out of a regionally shared worldview resulting from similar conditions of the time and place. Other sections recount legends or preach right-living. And still others document only genealogies or codes of law. These narrative variations, in addition to differences in language and lexicon throughout the five books, have led scholars to the JEPD (Jehovah, Elohim, Priestly, Deuteronomistic, and Redactor). This assigns sections of the Pentateuch to four specific authors based on language utilized, in addition to assuming the existence of an editor to compile the documents from the four and make them more consistent.
The narrative history which unfolds in the Deuteronomistic books comprises both a chronicle of centuries of events and explains why things happened as they did. It starts with the premise that the laws handed down by God near the Pentateuch’s start he then reaffirms to the leader of the Hebrews in Deuteronomy (meaning second law). This reaffirmation, through, does not simply dictate the codes of conduct, or the parameters of lawfulness. It also represents an agreement, a two way compact (or covenant) by which God agrees to protect the people in exchange for compliance with his laws. Elizabeth Vandiver notes that this bargain resembles a lord-vassal arrangement common in the Ancient Near East. By this logic, Jews do bad/worship other gods, God angry, Jews punished. Jews do good, make appropriate sacrifices and keep the Sabbath holy, God happy, Jews victorious in battle. Not only does this form of history provide a very resonant glimpse into a two-way theology, but it provides a very basic and convenient means for anyone trying to find order. It seems clear that the author(s) of the history believed this themselves. The narrative serves as a lesson as much as, if not more than, the story of the people. Most of all, it’s an account of the Jews’ relationship with God over time.
I find both of these perspectives compelling. If one treats the Old Testament as a piece of literature, I have no doubt that these outlooks very effectively deconstruct the text. But I’ve missed the point. Don’t Know Much and Great Authors give historical and literary accounts. But the influence of this book matters…the ideas, the God, matters. A confessional approach would suit best, especially since this primary source will not go on my list. So right now I don’t get to see as I should. But a pilgrim finds much, maybe God between the lines. At least I know the stories now. Check.
The outlooks I present deconstruct the text of the Old Testament; the first outlook, by assigning authorship, the second, by identifying the commitment and values of the author. The Pentateuch brings together the narratives and oral traditions that chronicle the tribe’s origins and ancestry. Some text, such as that of the creation, reads like a myth. Similarities in story and symbolism between this truly mythological account and those of other neighboring cultures implies the development of mythology out of a regionally shared worldview resulting from similar conditions of the time and place. Other sections recount legends or preach right-living. And still others document only genealogies or codes of law. These narrative variations, in addition to differences in language and lexicon throughout the five books, have led scholars to the JEPD (Jehovah, Elohim, Priestly, Deuteronomistic, and Redactor). This assigns sections of the Pentateuch to four specific authors based on language utilized, in addition to assuming the existence of an editor to compile the documents from the four and make them more consistent.
The narrative history which unfolds in the Deuteronomistic books comprises both a chronicle of centuries of events and explains why things happened as they did. It starts with the premise that the laws handed down by God near the Pentateuch’s start he then reaffirms to the leader of the Hebrews in Deuteronomy (meaning second law). This reaffirmation, through, does not simply dictate the codes of conduct, or the parameters of lawfulness. It also represents an agreement, a two way compact (or covenant) by which God agrees to protect the people in exchange for compliance with his laws. Elizabeth Vandiver notes that this bargain resembles a lord-vassal arrangement common in the Ancient Near East. By this logic, Jews do bad/worship other gods, God angry, Jews punished. Jews do good, make appropriate sacrifices and keep the Sabbath holy, God happy, Jews victorious in battle. Not only does this form of history provide a very resonant glimpse into a two-way theology, but it provides a very basic and convenient means for anyone trying to find order. It seems clear that the author(s) of the history believed this themselves. The narrative serves as a lesson as much as, if not more than, the story of the people. Most of all, it’s an account of the Jews’ relationship with God over time.
I find both of these perspectives compelling. If one treats the Old Testament as a piece of literature, I have no doubt that these outlooks very effectively deconstruct the text. But I’ve missed the point. Don’t Know Much and Great Authors give historical and literary accounts. But the influence of this book matters…the ideas, the God, matters. A confessional approach would suit best, especially since this primary source will not go on my list. So right now I don’t get to see as I should. But a pilgrim finds much, maybe God between the lines. At least I know the stories now. Check.
Labels:
Ancient Literature,
Deuteronomy,
Hebrews,
JEPD,
Jews,
Old Testament
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)