4.07.2009
On Romans Being Brutish
I think also part of the problem has been that some of the most characteristic traits of Roman society as a whole seem to fall outside of the purview of this project. By this, I mean that religion, superstition, and tradition dominate the thinking and actions of Romans. These anthropological bits and pieces are, sadly, outside of what I can realistically grapple with in this project.
Despite these limitations, I still have room to think about those aspects of Roman society that intrigue me most. Or said more clearly, aspects of human behavior that I feel the Romans exemplify—the manner in which institutions and socialization operate in human psychology and the creation of value and purpose at the loci of power. Watching Rome made me think a lot about that, and I was able to grapple with those issues a little in my post about the politics of domesticity and Pompeii, as well as my fascination with Augustus. Art in Rome has illustrated the how values emanate from power centers more than any other medium that I’ve discussed.
Two new points of data that deal less with these lofty bits and pieces and more with the thinking of day-to-day Romans are novels in Latin: Petronius’s Satyricon and Apuleius’s Metamorphoses or The Golden Ass. Satyricon (on which Fellini based his famous film of the same name, shown above) is a risqué narrative of the misadventures of everyday, brutish and sexually charged Roman plebeians. It paints a good picture of everyday life and language at that time and place. The Golden Ass follows a somewhat classic Roman literary premise that draws a great deal on Menander and New Comedy in its “lover finds lover, lover loses lover, lover refinds lover” structure. It also deals with some of the things I’m really interested in by dealing with form, transformation, and operating on the margins of society. These both make the list.
The historical Jesus next time.
2.04.2009
Schools of Thought in Rome, and the Intellectual World of Cicero
1.13.2009
Art and Philosophy in Rome, Part II
- Overreached: The curatorial staff should've taken everything out of the show that wasn't explicitly an object of antiquity. That stuff about the eruption of Vesuvius, the 19th century oil paintings of its eruption, and the attempts to copy those antiquities in later years was awful. They had plenty there to make an exceptional exhibition, and I think they added the other sections to make it more "current" or "timely". The last two parts, one of which featuring representations of the explosion of Vesuvius and the excavation, and another a painting by Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema depicting a sculpture garden (displaying alongside it many of the sculptures he painted), were the worst parts of the show, and must have taken a ton of time and money for all the necessary loans.
- Organized Poorly: All the bells and whistles added to the works to make the garden party theme more believable still didn't save it. According to the NGA's press release on Pompeii and the Roman Villa, the show is divided into five parts (this is news to me, as it is only vaguely alluded to in the brochure): "Patrons at Home", "Courtyards and Gardens", "Moregine" (the site near Pompeii where the frescos this section displays were discovered), "The Legacy of Greece", and "Rediscovery and Reinvention". This organization pained me--as a result of it, everything felt mismatched. Wall text seemed totally out of context or forced, especially in an environment were anything depicting myth got thrown in with "Greek Influence".
- Missed the Point of a Museum's Existence: I go to a museum to be able to engage as I please with some pieces, skip others, and spend ages staring at just a few. I know in a visiting exhibition, as opposed to a permanent collection spread, the intent is a little different. Everything just felt so Disneyland though, and it actually read to me like an academic's first foray into public history or art presentation, as if she felt like it had to be dumbed down to get the masses to appreciate and enjoy it. I know that the NGA can put on a first rate show that makes you feel smarter for having seen it and considered it. But in the end, this asked no questions of me...just put several objects together to fit the research that Matusch has been doing for years. Start with the art, not with the academic paper.
1.02.2009
Cato, History, and the Illusion of Conservativism
I often think of Cato these days when considering the Romans. Now that I too have lost pretty much of all hope in achieving the ideal that I once thought meant something, I think I can sympathize with him a little bit. Cato was a Roman senator, tough as nails apparently and a “real Roman”. Perhaps the most salient reason that I think about him lately is the motif he seems to represent. Horribly distrustful of the growing influence of Greek culture on Roman society, Cato called for a return to true Roman values. He believed they’d been disintegrating as a result of laziness and frivolity among the Roman upper classes. He blamed, among other things, the introduction of Greek thinking, carried on the back of Greek art, music, and philosophy, to Roman society
I note this because it seems that as the Romans approach the age of Augustus, the literature and poetry of Rome communicates a growing conflict that reflects Cato’s complaint. This is so at least among those lyricists and writers receiving the patronage (or disapproval) of Augustus and his chief arts liaison, Maecenas, and from a broader perspective among the political and societal programs of Augustus himself. By legislating and promoting certain societal values, Rome’s first emperor Augustus sought to recreate Rome according to an image, real or not, of time centuries before. This was the Rome of the Punic Wars, wherein Rome defeated the Carthaginians to the west (mid-third to mid-second centuries BC); the Macedonian Wars, fought at the same time as the Punic Wars and consequently knocking out every single Alexandrian kingdom to the east (with the exception of Egypt, which would fall under Roman control with the death of Cleopatra and the battle of Actium in 32 B.C.), and decimated the Gauls led by Vercingetorix to the north (this was Julius Caesar’s great achievement, called the Gallic Wars).
To be frank, I couldn’t care less about military history—tactics and generals, and so on and so forth. That stuff's for geeks and old men. My interest in these battles is understanding the heroes of Rome, and seeing the process by which Rome came to dominate the Mediterranean basin and what is now southern Europe and the Iberian peninsula. Furthermore, I wonder—how did a pseudo-democratic society manage such an expansion, and what tools did they use to effectively impose Roman control on regions so far away from the metropolis? Most critical to my study of these times is to see how cultural production reflects the societal dynamics put in motion by these events, and what kind of cultural identity resulted from them. Militaristic, certainly…but not just savage. This was a military controlled by the senate, a body whose norms and rules had been established over centuries. Rome’s successes—the glory of Rome, as it were—came to form the legend that would provide a basis for Roman patriotism, a critical component of Roman identity (given how dispersed Rome’s empire became, ethnic identity seems only a vague contributor to culture. Pedigree, however, is a different story. See my last post). The system that enabled these achievements, and the values that system socialized into those under its purview, would be just as critical to the identity, then, as the successes themselves.
Hence Cato’s complaint. As Rome becomes richer and more powerful, absorbing other cultures into its fold, the Greek civilization becomes one of the most popular societies of the past that Roman upper classes emulate. Art pieces are imported and copied constantly, and there’s a renewed interest in the writing, music, and philosophy of Rome’s Mediterranean neighbors. As noted in my last post, Rome did not just become Greek culturally. They took Greece and its products. The underlying dynamic of that process is one of the most characteristic components of Roman culture. And Cato hated it. He thought that Rome was losing sight of those values that had made them great, values that essentially made emulating Greece possible in the first place. Furthermore, he blamed a loss of patriotism for the greed that propelled the great Roman civil war forward that led to the rise and fall of Julius Caesar. He wouldn’t live to see defeats of Marc Antony and Brutus, and the eventual foundation of the Roman Empire under Augustus.
So what was for centuries a powerful Republic began to get shaky, and allowed for the eventual success of dictatorship (Don’t even think of making comparisons to the present—those conversations are so boring. If anything, look just at organizational dynamics. The United States is nothing like Rome, and doesn’t even approach the hegemony that Rome enjoyed. That is the first, and false, assumption made by those that compare the United States to Rome.) I was able in my last posts to show some of the culture that came out of Rome in the second and third centuries BC, right when Greece was on the wane and the Alexandrian kingdoms emerged. Now we enter a new era…the Roman Republic becomes pretty much the only game in town, and has swallowed up a bunch of other civilizations in the process. What does the last century of the Roman Republic look like? What were people thinking once Augustus came to poweer, and how does culture operate as a "technology of power"? How does understanding the context discussed above help to see the place of writers like Catallus, Horace, Virgil, and Ovid? What the heck was Cicero talking about, and how did philosophical schools like the Stoics and Epicureans come to dominate Roman philosophical thinking? Those are in the posts to come…posts that will be much richer as I understand what Romans like Cato and Augustus believed they lost, and wanted to get back to, and why we still read the things we do (answer: Virgil and Horace were on the Imperial payroll. Ovid was not by the time the Metamorphoses was written, making a cut and dry thesis on patronage a little difficult). And what the hell is a Christian, anyway?
For this post, I’m adding the extant parts of Livy’s history of the Roman Republic, From the Foundations of the City, to the list. Livy’s history covers several centuries of republican history, much like Herodotus’s Histories. Livy’s is interesting, though, because it’s written in a rhetorical, and thus somewhat persuasive style. His intent? Very much in line with what I’ve discussed in this post…he is forthright about his desire to demonstrate that the morals of Rome in his own time (59 BC through 17 AD) had degraded, and that everyone had to get back to the moral code on which Rome was based. His story that best encapsulates this commitment is the famous story of the Rape of Lucretia, in which sexual assault against the protagonist leads to the punishment of the man who did it and the eventual overthrow of the Etruscan kings and the establishment of the Roman Republic. Lucretia herself commits suicide, not because she is dishonored, but because she doesn’t want unchaste women in the future to ever have the option of lying about being raped as a cover for their adultery. Intense.
10.13.2008
The Etruscans and Emerging Italian Peninsula
What’s important for me to note is a lesson I can take with me as I encounter new nations that the Canon encounters in its forward movement (e.g., the Celts, the Cossacks, the Gauls, etc.) These are distinct nations with equally distinct cultures, very much rooted in the realities and circumstances of their respective times and places. With luck, they add a little something of their own to the Canon or become insular enough to escape co-optation and disintegration under foreign rule (see Roma). If unlucky, they fade away into the legend bin of conquered peoples (see Carthage).
The Canon, the list—that culture without a place. It’s a juggernaut. Domination and it have a productive, two-way relationship, and have scratched each others’ backs for millennia.
The Etruscans are among those who managed to add something to the Canon. The Romans carried with them Etruscan sensibilities and religious trappings (by the time the Romans emerged, the Etruscans practiced an amalgam of Greek religion and their own inherited forms of fortune telling and superstition). The art that remains with us gives a glimpse of a society that, although never confederating beyond a series of city-states, had a unique set of cultural practices and history.
Where did they come from, and what was their source? Herodotus suggests Lydia (incredible article here about that), which has some evidence. Indo-European or Phoenician seems equally plausible and a bit more fun to me. They have so much in common with the Greeks of Antiquity and before, with their own regional spin, that there’s something shared there.
In sculpture and decorative arts, we see some differences, but not many. The Etruscans were fantastic metalworkers, and their methods of filigree and granulation still confound scholars. In sculpture, the distance between the cultures is slimmer, although important differences represent the enormous impact that available materials can have on art. Compare these statues:
Similar form, but more gesture in the Etruscan. Whereas the Greeks used marble for sculpture, the Etruscans used terra cotta, a material that allowed for much greater experimentation with movement and creating detail in faces. Many works also show the same Orientalizing and Egyptian influence seen in the Greeks as well.
Despite these similarities, I have to ask myself, what did they add? Therein do I get the real perspective on the Etruscans. It seems likely to me that, at least as far as art is concerned, the Etruscans and Greeks of antiquity shared the same source material, the product most probably of significant cultural sharing as a result of trade networks. But as much as I like to read into the text that aesthetics represent, ultimately I think these are just fashionable stylings, stretched out over centuries. The Greeks themselves didn’t really create anything original until the 5th century, and that work was influenced by a major shift in how artisans thought about their work—an artistic commitment rooted in new ideas about the world. I doubt few of the values of the Greeks and Etruscans had much in common at all. As for the transmission of ideas were concerned, the Etruscans and other Italic people were their own men and women with their own assumptions and beliefs. They shared a vehicle of expression with the Greeks, and that’s all. Those contributed to the formation of the Roman people, not the aesthetic sensibility alone. And I’ll just have to see what that really means when I get on with the Romans themselves.
One thing I can peg now on an Etruscan to Roman link. They gave them the arch:
And the Romans ran with that just fine.