Showing posts with label Bruno Snell. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bruno Snell. Show all posts

7.01.2008

Order/Disorder Part 1: Limit

In a two part series to finish my exploration of the Greek body of text called Order/Disorder that I introduced in my last post, I discuss in two entries the basis of the moral code derived from a belief in a cosmic order, and the cultural production that resulted as adherence to that morality began to wane. Here, I build on the idea that order and logic provided the basis for Greek cultural and intellectual production throughout much of the Classical age, and suggest that this corresponds with the spread of Pythagoreanism.

The process of understanding Pythagoras has made the dynamic Greek civilization more understandable to me, especially as I’ve placed analyses by guys like Snell in a more informed historical context (It’s been very hard to find a discussion of Greek intellectual and cultural history that actually discussed sources). The Greek myths best known from the works attributed to the bard Homer had existed for centuries by the time Pythagoras appears in text in the early 6th century BCE, and a comparison of the two paradigms that the two aforementioned thinkers represent reveals the way in which thinking could open up, allowing for new perspectives of the self, the soul, and the nature of the physical world. The ancient Greek mythology that we all know and love relied on a set of assumption with only a very loose understanding of the body and what animates it, and believed in a pantheon of gods with all the caprices and brutality of human beings. Fate unfolds without any design, the threads of space knit together by the blind almost by chance, and as the tapestry forms across time, gods and men act and react within the physical world we can perceive with the senses. Kosmos (order), on the other hand, has purpose. The world operates according to a larger system—objects in space are units that operate as part of the whole, each with a value defined by an overarching structure. It gives man a new power—the ability to know and predict. It also gives him a personal space and individual choice (the source of the concept for the soul, be it material or immaterial).

Pythagoras gets credit for being the first transmitter of this kind of thinking, which would have far reaching effects on the Greek body of text that unfolded over the centuries following his life. Certainly Pythagoras was not the first to suggest some greater order to the universe—not only had he received an education in Egyptian and Babylonian traditions, he also continued the ancient Greek tradition attributed to Orpheus and his cult and before that, Dionysus. However, the rise of Pythagoreanism (at present ignoring his possible sources), corresponds to the rise of a different way of thinking—the growth of the cult of Apollo (which ceases to see him, and the muses which follow him, as very human-like creatures—anthropomorphic—and more like the ideal being and keeper of the order and of its revelation), and the burgeoning prevalence in text of references to the self and the individual mystical experience, that ecstatic moment of awe and wonder at the world and one’s place in it.

The nitty-gritty of Pythagoreanism revolves around number—but not as we would think of it; certainly, it’s almost violent to consider putting as much faith as they in what the contemporary mainstream would consider coincidence. Pythagoreanism itself took me quite a while to wrap my head around, and I had to research a great deal (thank you to Christiane L. Joost-Gaugier’s excellent book Measuring Heaven for its analysis of the growth of the Pythagorean school and its impact on art from the Classical period through the Middle Ages). I even visited New York City just for the day to attend a philosophy chat to which I was invited at Logos Bookstore on the Upper East Side just to ask the publishers who were sponsoring it some questions about Pythagoras’s number theory and ethics.

Fundamentally, it requires a different concept of numbers altogether, one not of magnitude (like how many apples are in a barrel, times 8 barrels, etc.), but of limit and definition—points in the infinite which, when seen as a series, provide structure for and make sense of the vast indefinite. The analogy of the monochord pulled it together for me—like on a guitar, where one can push the string an infinite number of places to create a new tone, one must have a sense of proportion with the original string’s length to really develop a system of tones based on ratio. Although the units one would choose to make those ratios (3/4, 8/9), etc., may seem arbitrary in an absolute sense, when utilized consistently in a defined system it makes a perfectly logical operating system. Thus, number does not have value in and of itself, but only relative to other points in the system, regardless of whether that system is constrained on a line, on a surface, in space, and in time.

I know it seems kind of nutty, but its actually wildly fun to figure out and really throw yourself into—no longer seeing just components, but the entire system and its intended operation. The Pythagoreans believed that the existence of ratios at all was not the order itself, but simply evidence, a reflection, of the larger system and design to all planes of existence (there are myriad approaches to the questions that this perspective allows relative to the end point of this whole system, the place of the individual within it, and so on. Please see my Plato post for just a couple of these responses by the thinkers known as the Pre-Socratics and by Plato himself). And so much Greek cultural and intellectual production reflects this assumption…statues that take into account the entire human form in order to create the image of an ideal man; temples where every angle and span work together in order to create a structure that inspires a sense of awe and majesty; an oral argument that makes the listener dive into his very beliefs and come away from the speech thinking differently about himself and his society; a social structure whose sole purpose is the just, and the good, and the right.

All these examples I list, though, hinge on a the creator’s commitment to a fundamental concept, and as I consider them it seems very clear to me how (certainly not why...that I'll explore later) the Greek text began to fall away from this manner of seeing artistic production into a world of disorder and confusion, as Greek civilization did by the early 3rd century BCE. The fundamental concept to which I refer is harmonia: the idea that the producer created a form of true beauty through its logical consistency, through its application of components whose value derived from a central rubric centered on the purpose of the form. Furthermore that the very purpose of creating the form was to coincide, or harmonize, with the greater order of existence. That is a question of morality—a commitment to the grand design by creating a system whose purpose worked toward that design’s intent. Thus it’s not a casting off of logic—certainly not—but a hazy idea of why one should use that logic at all. And that’s a matter of faith and personal purpose (I would suggest that the whole thing requires an initial inductive leap, but that’s because I’m an immoral person). As the Greeks discovered the power of a logical system, be it in music or oratory or art, many began to utilize it for their own personal gain instead of a moral code based on a concept of the universal order (see my post on rhetoric to read my own exploration of the philosophical problems caused by the work of the sophists, and a discussion of dialectic argument as a part of that inquiry). By the time Alexander rolls around in Greece, the body of text that we’ve inherited reflects a slowdown (although certainly not an end) to inquiry into the nature of order, and a greater priority given to functional knowledge created for the sake of application (See Euclid and Archimedes), without a coinciding discussion of the merit of the creator’s intent and the endpoint he or she pursues.

And so we see the philosophical discussion pushed to the edges in the new world of disorder. There, the schools and tribes of marginalized peoples who carried on the mystical traditions of the past would give birth to Stoicism, Skepticism, and of course, Christianity. Although Christianity will have to wait until the Italian peninsula and Rome, next post I’ll discuss Hellenistic literature, art, and other philosophical movements as I explore culture in a world of disorder.

10.27.2007

Art, Value and Order

I’ve just finished a book that my Dad sent me, called The Goal. It’s about business, specifically, manufacturing and management in a factory system. I own a business myself…have I ever told you that? I own a coffeeshop company, called Coup d’Etat Coffee Company. We operate a little coffeehouse in a bookstore in upper northwest Washington, D.C. I talk to my dad a lot about my business—he’s something of a management and fabrication guru, and I admire him very much, for many reasons beyond his professional success. And just these statements are very western, very American, even very Mid-Western the values they imply we pursue. Every step I take on this project brings me another step closer to understanding the values I’ve inherited, which has always been the point. I analyze myself in a new way with every word I write or read, and refresh my own perspective of that which makes me, me.
I would elaborate, but it would just be self-indulgence. I do know for sure that in the last few weeks, I’ve taken the time to explore some new paradigms, and forcibly construct my own framework on that which constitutes the “The West.” I still contend that the word “Western” describes a body of text, in which all sorts of works (music, philosophy, art, etc.) represent points within a giant network inter-connected values, ideas, traditions, and beliefs. In studying Greek art, as I have in the last few weeks, I’ve found examples of textual values showing through in very public and societal ways. I’ve also thought a lot on the manner in which these texts establish a truly cultural mainstream, and concluded again that one must distinguish the available text as its own discourse. This thought derives from the assumption that what one expresses publicly does not necessarily represent that which one thinks on an individual level, regardless if that level exists either consciously or unconsciously. The idea that first attracted me to this thesis occurred when writing my last post, when I noted that Pindar, the writer of odes, worked on commission. This fact opened up the possibility in my mind that Pindar wrote simply for his audience and for what they expected, distinct from his own ideas. I obviously cannot say whether or not this is the case—for all I know, people actually whole-heartedly believed in the values which influenced their artistic creations. I base my framework on the possibility of the sub-text and the detachment of the individual from his or her work made possible from this idea. Lastly, and more directly applicable to the art discussed in this post, I note the way in which I have accepted an idea of a Greek worldview, a thought expressed through art of a knowable order to the world by the stories and the proportions which Greek art seeks to present.
Art is a fertile ground. I’ve taken a lot of time to write this post partially because I’ve just happened to figure several things out when I did. More importantly though, art provides an almost boundless context for exploring a culture’s values, and provides far more room than other disciplines for understanding the possible realities of the time one studies. I’ve taken advantage of this, but not without a great deal of caution. Developments in my thesis and framework have relied a great deal on what I’ve learned about Greek sculpture and architecture, in addition to writings I’ve considered by Bruno Snell and Bertrand Russell.
In sculpture, that which emerged which one could categorize as distinctly Greek emerged in what Janson’s calls the archaic and classical periods. Preceding periods, called the geometric and orientalizing, chronologically, show the rise of pottery-making and the shift from clay and bronze stone sculpture. One marks the shift in the craft of forming statues in terms of the proportion, which he or she defines in terms of the relationship of measurements—face, body, limbs, etc. Proportion, though, is a funny thing. As Greek statuary shifts into the archaic and classical periods (those periods which I noted as being distinctly Greek), a new set of proportions emerge in the depiction of the human form which Janson’s identifies as a shift toward “naturalism.” Here, Greek statuary depicts human figures with clearly defined body shape and movement. The body in these statues maintains a life-like contortion as sculptors explored both muscular systems reacting to each other as a single unit, and experimented with a whole range of physical positions and their effect on the body’s appearance.
Monumental architecture contributed to the development of statuary a great deal, in addition to developing a genre of craftsmanship all its own. A formulaic style in monumental construction developed throughout Greek civilization, expressed in the well-known constructions of pillars and triangular roofs. Comparisons in structure within the set of existing temples reveal regional trends in pillar design and the framing of frieze art, or the series of statues sculpted into the marble above the pillars. Some of these friezes, in addition to the statuary mounted within the A-shaped space under the roofing, which Janson’s refers to as the pediment, represent an enormous proportion of the sculpture produced by Greeks in many mainland and island city-states.
Art comprises a body of text which has influenced my framework by helping me to understand trends and frequencies, and has contributed to my thesis by showing how these trends create a societal and cultural mainstream. The extent to which one abides, or truly believes, is a matter of simple conjecture on my part. But as always, I can only hope to play the sculptor myself by creating possibilities, from which I can conclude as I would like once I read and analyze the primary sources themselves. I will venture to state, though, that I think it likely that text exists within both known Greek statuary and monumental architecture which suggests an understandable and comprehensive Greek worldview. This perspective is one that assumes that the perceived world has an absolute order and that the order can be found by mankind. This underlies the view that reason dominated the Greeks—that the belief in an unseen order, regardless of its source, inspired a societal impulse to value and categorize the physical world.
I, for one, must still (I think responsibly, given my own beliefs) contend that this represents only the trend in the body of text which we know, and from which we can extrapolate possibilities and conclusions. I have gained a great deal of insight from two writers in particular, Bruno Snell and Bertrand Russell (and I’m sure there are myriad more from whom I could learn a lot), portray the available text as a sample of the culture of the period at large. I, believing in the possibility that the author does not believe what he writes, take issue. Nonetheless, their insights into the body of the text at hand have been indispensable to me, and deserve discussion in the context of my own current reporting of my project.
The Discovery of the Mind, written by Bruno Snell, has served as an enormous catalyst to my thinking about existing Greek text. My friend Trip loaned me the book based on what he knew of my interests, and ultimately he, predictably, performed brilliantly. The scholar argues in his book that a within the Greek body of text, a shift occurs in language from describing the spatial, including the very operations of the human being, to the individual. He assumes the Greeks derived much of their basic assumptions on the works of Homer (an argument to which I must concede, based on the evidence that he and others present), in whose works little language refers to the individual. From that perspective, a basic acknowledgment develops in the available text of the role of the human spirit, passion, and free will on the course of human events. This development enabled the Greeks to develop science, which relied on a break from existing norms handed down from tradition in order to allow for creativity and the individual intellect. This theory relies on a very solid body of text (Snell is a classicist, he studies language itself), and presents an argument that is logically possible, given his source material.
Another paradigm comes from a behemoth, Bertrand Russell. It has lingered with me for months, but I needed to formulate my own framework for understanding the “West” before I could fully appreciate its logic. Russell’s basis for his History of Western Philosophy is the conflict between science and religion in the world, between which philosophy lies. He argues that the primal and individual instinct inspires this middle ground, and the rest, as I understand, seeks to know the unknown order beyond that which we cannot see. One truth comes from the stories handed down from ages before us, the other, one can derive him or herself through the basic tools of logic. It implies religion as power center—by seeking the truth ourselves we threaten the ability of religion, and as the case may be the state, to order society according to its own truth. Man v. Nature, that which we discussed all the way back in Mesopotamia, finds a logical manifestation in Russell’s paradigm. This argument also compels me toward a specific framework as I learn about the Greeks, and beyond.
But I have a fundamental problem with both arguments, despite how much I’ve gained from them. In both cases, the scholars make their conclusions as if probabilities for the workings or ordering principle of the whole at the time when the writer of the source text produces. But I cannot accept that the writer truly believed what he wrote—even if he or she (Sappho!) really did, because we cannot know for sure. The conclusions that one can make from text are severely limited when one assumes this disconnection. He or she can only remark on trends in the text—enormously important, but limited to the text itself, as if we read a single book, and made nothing but speculations about the author or the world around him or her. But I prefer it that way. At least we know we only deal with possibilities, probabilities, In a greater sense, at least we acknowledge that we, knowlingly or unknowlingly, confine ourselves to postulates confined by our own paradigms and socializations.
That said, I can still use Russell and Snell. Even more, I’ll say that I loved their ideas. Loved them. They totally changed my point of view, which is why I spent so much time thinking about them and making them work. Their ideas, in combination with the images of Greek statues and monuments, inspire to formulate my own ideas of a possible Greek worldview. I imagine the possibility that this body of text indicates a reverence for the capacity to reason, and for man’s ability to see and appreciate the physical world of units within an order. When one observes the proportions of a statue or the stories represented by the figures that decorate the impressive marble structures, we see the source of good and bad, the body of text that lays out the rubric by which we value everything. Greek sculpture does not reveal an attempt at the realistic, but an attempt to represent the epitome of beauty. The pillared temples house the mythologies that set the points of reference in our universally applicable scale.
I imagine that this body of text is the primary tool for transmitting a message. It communicates that man exists situated on a scale between animals and gods, and he has no soul. He is a collection of traits and qualities, valued according to an inherited criteria. Passion or individual human action do not create works of beauty—instead we are touched by the Gods or muses to have a momentarily enhanced capacity to reason, and to see more clearly the order in our physical space. This allows for the possibility that beauty does not exist in the way we understand it, as a personal or individual experience, nor does it derive from some eternal spirit. Good and bad exists on the same scale as more and less ordered, respectively. A statue, whose face expresses a serene indifference to the world as if fully connected to reason, expresses this concept at its heart. Man himself has value according to rules which we can know and his capacity to reason. The universal paradigm gives birth to virtue, and elevates Greek society itself as the pursuer, and even guardian, of the true nature of things.
I know it’s a lot of ideas right now. Shit, you should have seen it in the numerous pages I wrote before. But this is art, and this is the impact it has had on my perspective. I hope that each upcoming post has as much earth-shattering effect on my point of view, because I love it. I do. So as our body of text progresses chronologically, we do not escape order—it morphs, and certainly the democratization of knowledge of order, i.e. reason, has some rough patches. My next post will likely move into these issues, and Snell’s idea of the birth of the individual in text, as I discuss the first tragedians, Euripides, Sophocles, and Aeschylus. After that, a post on the great historians, Herodotus and Thucydides, one on the age of Socrates wherein I’ll discuss Aristophanes and Xenophon, and then the articles I’m dreading—Plato and Aristotle. Maybe the work I’ve done this last few weeks will pay off with them—I have an ever forming framework to make him a little more understandable. And I mull over the prospect of a longer essay discussing my understanding of the Greek worldview, and the process of understanding it, and most of all its application to my own life. It would be very cathartic, a kind of final exam before I move on from the Greeks, and onto the Etruscans, the Romans, and the early Christian church.
To close, I want to reflect that as a teenager, I read C.S. Lewis’s The Screwtape Letters. In the book, a demon writes in a letter how silly it is that humans look at past points in one’s life as passé. When I read the book I was probably 15 or 16, and I embraced its message as one of value; I resolved never to consider other stages in my life with condescension. But this, my friends, is much easier said than done. It requires both perspective of the past, and humility now. This lesson has served me as more than an interesting exercise: it is a constraint in the consideration of my life and, more specifically and germane to this post, that which I study.
I think writing is the part of my journey that inhibits condescension of my own past perspectives. I note all of this because these last few weeks during which you’ve heard nary a squeak from me have not passed without activity in this project. Hardly the case. But I can’t content myself with just laying back and basking in the glory of my own achievements. The brutal articulation of laying down words makes the process both difficult and real. Hopefully, the ever-changing text and understanding that forms the foundation of my ideas will creep from the spaces between letters and punctuation marks, and you will see what this project has achieved in me.