Showing posts with label Roman History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Roman History. Show all posts

2.07.2010

And without further adieu...


And so on a Saturday night, when I should be out and about Buenos Aires, I'm here, with you. Seems like no better time and place to finish what I started, or at least, end this stage. What began as a chronicle of an escapism has since grown into a full fledged passion, so to write my final post of this particular blog signifies only that the project still progresses, just transforming. Give me a few months of chrysalis time, as I'm having to learn a thing or two, things I never intended to have to know, but now take up most of my time in learning. In the meantime, here we are; at the beginning of the end for the Romans, and the end of the beginning for the Christians. And quite interestingly, I still linger on a philosopher of the same period, the third century CE, little thought of nowadays: Plotinus, the Neo-Platonist—contemporary of Origen, and author of the Enneads. He, along with a few others like Ovid, Praxiteles and Bertrand Russell himself, have become my friends. Their thoughts stay with me, and have helped me to form my own (as good friends have a tendency to do). I certainly never expected such a deep friendship with these men in particular, but I suppose friendships have that tendency as well.

In my other chapter, the one during which I started this blog, I ran a little coffeehouse. While working behind the counter there one day a few years ago, an elderly Italian man and I began a joking conversation about the actual divinity of the Divine brand chocolate bars which I sold next to the cash register. Having just read a bit about the early Greek philosophers of the Italian peninsula and the Plato, I think I surprised him a little by paraphrasing those cats in constructing a metric for divinity, and even knowing who the hell Parmenides was. Flash forward a few months, I'm editing newsletters about Plotinus for the spiritual fellowship he runs in New York City, a group devoted the concepts shared by Plato and the neo-Platonists (like Plotinus), several Indian scholars, etc.

You see, the work of Plotinus had a heap ton of antecedents, like Pythagoras and Plato, and some eery parallels with a group of yoga-practicing philosophers a hop, skip, and jump east in what today we call India. I certainly could spend my fair share of time reflecting on the probability of real life connections (and even hard anthropological and linguistic evidence that suggests it) between the Dionysian cults, Orphic mystery schools, and certain strains of philosophy originating in South Asia and Iran. We shan't, though, dwell on that here. Relative to the project at hand, I take more pleasure in noting a few particulars in the strain of thinking I think they all share, as it would have a tremendous impact on the thinking that still tenaciously lingers among us today.

I could never do justice to paraphrasing Plotinus, nor would I dare to try in any serious way. Suffice it to say that many call Plotinus's teacher, Ammonius Saccas, the first neo-Platonist, and like Plato they had concluded that our senses deceive us. That which we feel and experience on a physical level, that which we believe to be true based on that which we perceive, is not the whole story. It is, in fact, flawed, whereas the world we think, though the perfection of mathematics and forms, is real. The rest is just a copy. Although we can perceive the real, thought world from hints all around us, it is through logic alone that we truly blaze a trail toward the root source of truth. That truth cannot be defined, but gives truth to all other things. It's the idea without source, the logos of this world. Jesus, I go bananas over that kind of talk.

Speaking of Jesus, I won't go as far as to say this was mainstream thinking, by any means, but as soon as the process of Hellenization got its claws into a recently-not-Jewish Christianity, Greek logical styles and a newly developing Christian theology became fast friends, which we see as early as the Gospel John. John is by far the most mystical of the four gospels, and even refers to God as “logos.” It wasn't much of a leap, after all...once the mythological groundwork had been laid and the lines had been drawn between believers and non-believers, the thinking set among the Christian crowd began to hash out the theology for the relatively new religion. Why? Not sure. My guess is that they wanted to develop a consistent world view, ethics, and morality, based on the death of Jesus, his relationships to God, and to a lesser extent his teachings. What we're looking at, then, is a lot of conditional statements, like “if Jesus is God's son, and Jesus came to save man by dying for him, then...” [enter here 1700 years of more discussion pretty much all based on that]. But these were the first guys to hash this stuff out, and they became known as the church fathers, among them a contemporary and fellow alumnus of Ammonius Saccas, Origen (they'll all go on the list). Frankly, I don't think it's much of a leap to connect Greek style philosophizing with Judeo-Christian religion, especially as far as souls and God are concerned, so I'm hardly surprised at how deeply rooted Christian mysticism is in Greek logic.

However, we can't all be mystics, and hashing out the particulars of an entire religion didn't occur without a fair number of disagreements. What I can't fully wrap my head around is the drive for orthodoxy. I can see why at the beginning the presentation of a clear message was so important. By the 200's, though, creating a Catholic orthodoxy seemed of vital importance to a lot of extremely smart people. I suppose there's some measure of brand management involved, but I think Russell says it best, when he says in the History of Western Philosophy, “The separatist movements in themselves are not surprising, but it is curious that they should have been associated with very subtle and obstruse theological questions.” And separatist movements there were, both within the orthodoxy and entirely outside of it. Gnosticism, a very mystic and very anti-Jewish Christian sect, had at its basis on a separate creation story to validate the “real world is fake” concept. Manichaeism, similar to Gnosticism but drawing more on Zoroastrian traditions, had split off in a manner similar to Gnosticism in that they had separate bishops in certain cities apart from the Catholic ones (although it was not uncommon for spiritual leaders to have leanings one way or another). More importantly, both of these schools had their fair share of adherents.

Within the church, disagreements arose among those fully within the fold on the subject, like whether God was actually higher than Jesus or if they were equal. That matter in particular led to the development of a school called Aryanism (who believed that God was higher), which will play a much greater role later in our story. But for now, let's focus on the fact that despite these disagreements, these thinkers used similar vocabulary, similar units of analysis (soul, body, relative value), and similar methodology by which they developed logical streams of thought, which alone indicates to me that they were all dealing with one another on very Hellenic terms.

I think certainly the circumstances of the third century within the Roman empire made all of these religions relevant to people of all classes. Following the death of the emperor Commodus, the son of the “last of the five good emperors” Marcus Aurelius, Rome began a decline in its fortunes from which it never fully recovered. Although experiencing a brief respite under the Severan dynasty, the office of emperor changed hands constantly, as the murder of one would lead to yet another conflict over his successor. This time, however, the path to succession was hardly clear, and either generals would lay claim to the title or ensure that the highest bidder took the throne. Meanwhile, the the northern and eastern borders had started to crumble, with incursions by Celts, Germanic tribes, Parthians, and Persians. Efficiency and effectiveness of the military crumbled without strong leadership in the top-down Roman system, and resources were stretched. The cornerstone of Roman commerce, its expansive network of secure trade routes, began to buckle at the weight of widespread banditry. Rather than risk it in the poorer and unstable cities, many of the richest in the western empire fled to country estates and stayed there. More wealth stayed in the resource rich eastern empire, causing further disequilibrium. In order to combat these failures in governance, the emperor Diocletian divided the empire into four administrative regions in 286 CE, in a move that was as much a political power sharing agreement as anything. The official art of the period tries to communicate a message of unity among the emperors, but I guess we know how that turned out.


Much as religion and superstition had seen a rise during the period after Alexander's death and the wars between his generals, religion saw a major upswing in the third century CE as well. Instability and uncertainty about the future has a pretty big effect on people, and I'm sure that rewards guaranteed in another kingdom beyond this one had a pretty strong attraction. Jesus is often seen in art as a healer, and a miracle worker, even a magician. Christianity, although going into and out of periods of systematic repression on government orders, began to reach critical mass numbers. What was once a fringe movement had become, essentially, the only organized political force among the populace. Christians held political office (they were some of the few who could read), and their numbers among the poor had overwhelmed the empire's efforts to suppress its growth.

So when Constantine need a victory in battle, a part of his larger (and ultimately successful) effort to reunite the empire under one emperor, he raised the Christian flag. His army, mostly Christians, answered the call. No, Christianity did not become the state religion (that would happen later under Theodoseus), only the favored one, and the recipient of a great deal of money from the state (especially in the new administrative capital of the empire, Constantinople). Nor did Christianity acquire a central leadership until many years later.

However, orthodoxy rears its head again. Constantine demanded that the Christians settle their theological differences and at the Council of Nicea, they (kind of) did, at least as far as God=Jesus=Spirit is concerned. However, bishops in various regions chaffed at the idea of receiving orders and doctrine from central church leadership in Rome—many theological differences followed regional lines, and some bishops had greater influence in their corner of the empire based on their positions on theological matters. These divides would persist for centuries. In demanding orthodoxy, Constantine made the Christian religion a technology of state power. By controlling the ideas and establishing a mainstream, one takes possession of the most important and useful tool for control.

As I conclude, that's really been the theme, hasn't it. At least, that's how I've seen it and written it. Control, power, values. In everything there is an order, and aesthetics and semiotics themselves create and destroy institutions. Understand what we consider beauty, consonance, and even the good, (and who's paying for it) and we discover more about values, human organization, communication, and the means of domination itself.

In the next couple of weeks I'll fully update the list up to about everything I've studied up until now. Then it's onto writing the proposal for 2.0, and a link to the new website which will initially have only the project proposal, but hopefully by September 2010 will be up and running. For now, though, we close antiquity, and a very, very long prelude. Maybe I'll even make “Western Mysticism” an “interest” on my Facebook profile. Three years later, I'm still working on this, more passionately then ever, and I'll post the link to the new site as soon as the proposal is up. Until then, adieu.

11.05.2009

The Historical Jesus-Parables as Data Point



I am distressed to learn that history has yet again only further deepened my sense of general meaninglessness and disappointment. How is it that, after months of studying the Historical Jesus, his Jewish antecedents, and technological and scholarly discussion on the intent of his words that I can feel less inspired by the story of Jesus than almost anything else I've studied. Blasphemous, I know, and I'm sure my mom's feelings will again be crushed upon learning that I can't muster even a scintilla of inspiration or even panacea from knowing more about Jesus. I'm sure that's the general trend among things when one asks too many question, digs too deep—stripping away the golds flakes of mystique to reveal a leaden form. What solutions do we, the faithless, have, in the end? I guess I can't yet accept that at least some openness to a sense of truth will someday result in some kind of good feeling.

So here I am, yet again, discussing the particularities in stone cold form those ideas and stories that people once held and still hold as sacred. Just another naked emperor. The region in which Jesus was purported to have lived, Galilea, was the backwoods region of a kingdom called Judea (still unbelievable to me, and perhaps this is something I should work on, that a region a third the size of my state could manage such cultural diversity...to consider later, I suppose). Judea had undergone the influence of Hellenic culture for centuries, beginning with the carving up of Alexander's conquered territory into separate kingdoms. After significant fighting, Judea had come under Seleucid rule, which was later overthrown by the Maccabee clan (enter the Chanukkah tradition, by the way). The Maccabees founded the Hasmonean dynasty, who ruled the Kingdom of Judea for over a century, when a series of internal conflicts eventually led to the establishment of the Herodian dynasty, which would become the client government of the nascent Romen Empire via its chosen king, the half Jewish Herod. Herod was jealous, suspicious, and murdererous. However, he also constructed Caesaria, which would become a bustling and successful port city, and a new temple, ruled over by the priests, or levites, of a sect of Judaism called the Sadducees. Judea had a greater population than any other Roman province during Herod's rule, and enjoyed a very cosmopolitan and mixed population in the cities.

The Sadducees were, by Jewish law, not only the religious elite but also law givers. They collaborated closely with Herod and his Roman patrons, most notably among them Mark Anthony, in maintaining order throughout Judea. However, this was more difficult than it simply seemed. For centuries the Jews had rejected foreign domination. They conflated as a part of their religious worldview their governance, their culture, and the religion that dictated the precepts, rituals, and practices of that culture. The Maccabees exemplify the tradition of armed conflict against foreign occupiers and rules, following the attempt by the Seleucid leadership to Hellenize Judea by outlawing temple rituals, circumcision, etc. This tension between Hellenism and Judaism remained markedly present strain in the thinking of the community for centuries to follow. A notable aspect of this strain, the Maccabees and their followers had targeted the Hellenes, but had additionally targeted their Jewish collaborators. Those that complied with demands to Hellenize were punished with death. Flash forward and one can see why a certain antagonism existed within Judaism, especially towards the priestly class intent on payoffs and political power through their position as temple leadership.

This Judaism existed under Roman dominance, fractured itself by decades of civil war, where we meet Julius Caesar, Pompey, Augustus, Brutus, and Mark Antony. The whole Mediterranean was in flux, where people reached out for strategic political allegiances for their very survival, seeking to protect themselves and the institutions that gave them power. These centers of power were themselves legitimized by declared divine mandate, and the complicity of soothsayers and priests.

Enter into this world Jesus of Nazareth, son of Joseph. There is no evidence whatsoever to suggest he was born in Bethlehem or lived with his family in exile, nor is there any evidence of the purported edicts that would have made his family go to either Bethlehem or leave Galilea. He was a tradesman, like his father. Here begins centuries of storytelling and work to recreate the life of Jesus, his ministry, his beliefs, and his death. My next post will dig in greater detail into the myth that the early Christian church created around the actual man, to both explain the failure that Jesus's death before the coming of God represented (called, in scholarly circles, the criterion of dissimilarity, or embarrassment, that makes more valid certain aspects of the Jesus story), and influence of the period in which which the gospels were written. I change course now, from historical narrative to that which most interests me and is most relevant to this project.

Although the storyline illuminates these texts with regards to how religions form and circumstances that inform them, this project is first and foremost a chronicle of the project. So what, if anything, does this have to do with it? A tough question, even as it seems to me. This project matters because it's about sources and data. However, as any social scientist or historian working with primary sources will tell you, data is most of all a function of strength and validity of the source material. Distinguishing the sayings and intent of Jesus and the writings of those whose works would become the New Testament matters because of the context, and subsequently the intent of the work. The writers of the New Testament produced their texts decades after Jesus death, during the height of the first Jewish revolt and the first examples of the systematic persecution of Christians under the Roman Empire. That being said, even distinguishing Jesus work from his followers, most notably the work of Paul, opens Jesus' sayings open to an interpretation which, on one side, he demonstrates a greater influence on one side and on the other, an entirely different school.

At the center of this debate in studies of the historical Jesus is what is called eschatology, apocalypticism, and millenarieanism. But how does one define any of these terms? Scholars debate this matter presently, especially those who believe Jesus never intended his words to mean that the cosmos or history itself would end, but instead think he meant to create a Kingdom of God brought about by ideas, and self-exploration and those who believe he actually wanted to suggest the coming of a power great than the Roman Empire itself. Such a coming would bring about a great social upheaval, bringing justice and order for the people who were oppressed and downtrodden that the world as one knew it at the time would be totally unrecognizable, if even existant in the physical sense.

A quick note. Eschatology means the end of history as we know it. Human experience will cease under its present precepts and will exist under its present precepts and will exist under an illuminative constraint brought about by the arrival of God or his vicerroy (in this case Jesus). Apocalypse, or apocalyptic, is the physical manifestation of this eschatological vision—the signs, the events, and most of all the coming of a messiah or king that promises a new order. Millenarianism is simply the end of an earthly period, with the expectation of a new one's beginning.

Believe it or not, Nobel Prize winner Albert Schweizer is one of the big names in this field, as are Strauss, Kant, Norman Perrin, and Jon Dominic Crossan, Marcus Borg, and myriad others. I've read Borg and Crossan, and their views diverge. For me, and my intent, their varied description have a great impact on my own sense of what could have influenced Jesus' thinking.

After all, Judea was a very Hellenicized region, despite the best attempts of the Jewish leadership to keep it out. Cynic, Stoic, and Epicurean teachers would have traveled as itinerant teachers, speaking in Koine Green and describing the world view of their school. If Jesus actually believed a coming of God was near, that he was the Messiah, then I think his sources were more Judaic in origin. The Essenes, an ascetic sect of Judaism that had a major problem with the priestly classes of Judaism, would have certainly had an influence on this. John the Baptist comes to mind in this regard.

On the other hand, did Jesus want to bring about a kingdom of men, ruled by a new ethic? This viewpoint was especially during the age of liberalism. Kant, especially, stands out. Within this paradigm, Jesus actually wished to convey that the kingdom of God could happen by our actions—he describes, in this sense, not an apocalyptic eschatology but a prophetic eschatology. Some say this misconstrues the history. In our life and times is seems to have a greater resonance. Instead of the actual son of God, Jesus is a sage, a learned person, taking something from cynicism, stoicisim, even platonism. These philosophies converge to create a kingdom of ethic that is lived, and not necessarily created by a government.

So which is it? Is he the true king of the Jews, the bringer of a new kingdom? Did he miscalculate, and is that miscalculation conjured up by those who later chronologized his life by suggesting a new interpretation and a second coming?

I believe that Jesus was a philosophical and ethical leader, who was informed by the abundance of Hellenic teachers and the need that the historical and cultural context created for turning inward, when outward action could only fail. Whether in the course of his teaching he became convinced of his own holiness, I don't know. I take the middle ground, and consider the sayings of Jesus as a separate data point, distinct from the New Testament and the gospels that narrate his life. He was a man with thorough knowledge of the limits of the hierarchy to bring about change and knew that change would happen only by personal commitment to a new morality.

1.02.2009

Cato, History, and the Illusion of Conservativism

I often think of Cato these days when considering the Romans.  Now that I too have lost pretty much of all hope in achieving the ideal that I once thought meant something, I think I can sympathize with him a little bit.  Cato was a Roman senator, tough as nails apparently and a “real Roman”.  Perhaps the most salient reason that I think about him lately is the motif he seems to represent.  Horribly distrustful of the growing influence of Greek culture on Roman society, Cato called for a return to true Roman values.  He believed they’d been disintegrating as a result of laziness and frivolity among the Roman upper classes.  He blamed, among other things, the introduction of Greek thinking, carried on the back of Greek art, music, and philosophy, to Roman society

I note this because it seems that as the Romans approach the age of Augustus, the literature and poetry of Rome communicates a growing conflict that reflects Cato’s complaint.  This is so at least among those lyricists and writers receiving the patronage (or disapproval) of Augustus and his chief arts liaison, Maecenas, and from a broader perspective among the political and societal programs of Augustus himself.  By legislating and promoting certain societal values, Rome’s first emperor Augustus sought to recreate Rome according to an image, real or not, of time centuries before.  This was the Rome of the Punic Wars, wherein Rome defeated the Carthaginians to the west (mid-third to mid-second centuries BC); the Macedonian Wars, fought at the same time as the Punic Wars and consequently knocking out every single Alexandrian kingdom to the east (with the exception of Egypt, which would fall under Roman control with the death of Cleopatra and the battle of Actium in 32 B.C.), and decimated the Gauls led by Vercingetorix to the north (this was Julius Caesar’s great achievement, called the Gallic Wars).

To be frank, I couldn’t care less about military history—tactics and generals, and so on and so forth.  That stuff's for geeks and old men.  My interest in these battles is understanding the heroes of Rome, and seeing the process by which Rome came to dominate the Mediterranean basin and what is now southern Europe and the Iberian peninsula.  Furthermore, I wonder—how did a pseudo-democratic society manage such an expansion, and what tools did they use to effectively impose Roman control on regions so far away from the metropolis?  Most critical to my study of these times is to see how cultural production reflects the societal dynamics put in motion by these events, and what kind of cultural identity resulted from them.  Militaristic, certainly…but not just savage.  This was a military controlled by the senate, a body whose norms and rules had been established over centuries.  Rome’s successes—the glory of Rome, as it were—came to form the legend that would provide a basis for Roman patriotism, a critical component of Roman identity (given how dispersed Rome’s empire became, ethnic identity seems only a vague contributor to culture.  Pedigree, however, is a different story.  See my last post).  The system that enabled these achievements, and the values that system socialized into those under its purview, would be just as critical to the identity, then, as the successes themselves.

Hence Cato’s complaint.  As Rome becomes richer and more powerful, absorbing other cultures into its fold, the Greek civilization becomes one of the most popular societies of the past that Roman upper classes emulate.  Art pieces are imported and copied constantly, and there’s a renewed interest in the writing, music, and philosophy of Rome’s Mediterranean neighbors.  As noted in my last post, Rome did not just become Greek culturally.  They took Greece and its products.  The underlying dynamic of that process is one of the most characteristic components of Roman culture.  And Cato hated it.  He thought that Rome was losing sight of those values that had made them great, values that essentially made emulating Greece possible in the first place.  Furthermore, he blamed a loss of patriotism for the greed that propelled the great Roman civil war forward that led to the rise and fall of Julius Caesar.  He wouldn’t live to see defeats of Marc Antony and Brutus, and the eventual foundation of the Roman Empire under Augustus.

So what was for centuries a powerful Republic began to get shaky, and allowed for the eventual success of dictatorship (Don’t even think of making comparisons to the present—those conversations are so boring.  If anything, look just at organizational dynamics.  The United States is nothing like Rome, and doesn’t even approach the hegemony that Rome enjoyed.  That is the first, and false, assumption made by those that compare the United States to Rome.)  I was able in my last posts to show some of the culture that came out of Rome in the second and third centuries BC, right when Greece was on the wane and the Alexandrian kingdoms emerged.  Now we enter a new era…the Roman Republic becomes pretty much the only game in town, and has swallowed up a bunch of other civilizations in the process.  What does the last century of the Roman Republic look like?  What were people thinking once Augustus came to poweer, and how does culture operate as a "technology of power"?  How does understanding the context discussed above help to see the place of writers like Catallus, Horace, Virgil, and Ovid?  What the heck was Cicero talking about, and how did philosophical schools like the Stoics and Epicureans come to dominate Roman philosophical thinking?  Those are in the posts to come…posts that will be much richer as I understand what Romans like Cato and Augustus believed they lost, and wanted to get back to, and why we still read the things we do (answer: Virgil and Horace were on the Imperial payroll.  Ovid was not by the time the Metamorphoses was written, making a cut and dry thesis on patronage a little difficult).  And what the hell is a Christian, anyway?

For this post, I’m adding the extant parts of Livy’s history of the Roman Republic, From the Foundations of the City, to the list.  Livy’s history covers several centuries of republican history, much like Herodotus’s Histories.  Livy’s is interesting, though, because it’s written in a rhetorical, and thus somewhat persuasive style.  His intent?  Very much in line with what I’ve discussed in this post…he is forthright about his desire to demonstrate that the morals of Rome in his own time (59 BC through 17 AD) had degraded, and that everyone had to get back to the moral code on which Rome was based.  His story that best encapsulates this commitment is the famous story of the Rape of Lucretia, in which sexual assault against the protagonist leads to the punishment of the man who did it and the eventual overthrow of the Etruscan kings and the establishment of the Roman Republic.  Lucretia herself commits suicide, not because she is dishonored, but because she doesn’t want unchaste women in the future to ever have the option of lying about being raped as a cover for their adultery.  Intense.