Showing posts with label Italic and Roman Art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Italic and Roman Art. Show all posts

1.13.2009

Art and Philosophy in Rome, Part II

Pompeii and the Roman Villa, now on display at the National Gallery of Art, displays an impressive abundance of antiquities in a city built on the classical tradition.  Washington D.C. lacks a sizeable permanent antiquities collection of its own (Dumbarton Oaks comes close, but focuses largely on Byzantine era antiquities and is downright cute in its size), so I anticipated the show as a rare treat at observing something classical in my hometown.  I did so twice: the first time out of excitement, and the second time out of defiance.  My friend Tyler Green, writer of Modern Art Notes, had heard through the grapevine that the show was poorly curated and told me so before I visited.  As a lover of all things classical, I didn't want to believe it.  But sometimes one just has to face facts.  Despite so much good stuff on such an oft studied topic, I thought Pompeii and the Roman Villa was junk.  Where did they go wrong?  Did the staff overreach?  Organize poorly?  Miss the point of a museum's existence in virtually all of the material they presented?  All of the above, I say.

Drawn largely from collections in Naples and the surrounding region of Campania, home to Herculaneum and Pompeii (of volcanic destruction fame), the exhibition focuses on the Republican and Imperial Roman decorative arts of the seaside villas around the Bay of Naples.  The premise for the show itself is a good one...the domestic art and architecture of the Roman elite.  It's a fascinating subject in its own right, as it touches on many of the subjects related to memorializing one's pedigree (which I touched on in my last post on Roman art, here), as well as showing the infinitely more political side of Roman life.  That's right, more political side.  Monumental architecture so known and loved (and about which I'll write more in the future), sought to commemorate the victories of Rome's sundry senators, generals, and emperors.  It deified them, and shrouded them with symbolism that would resonate in the mind of the cadres of uneducated plebes who would be compelled to fight, either in the army or in riots, to further the political ends of the state leadership.  Monumental art is just public oratory in shapes and forms, with a premise and pursuit.

Domestic art is certainly not without pursuit. It's just more crafty about it, like wearing your nicest suit to the interview, or buying a new dress for a gala.  It's about appearances to those whom you hope might propel you or your family higher on the social hierarchy, or increase your wealth through marriage or the umpteen other kinds of alliance that manifest in the sphere of politics.  These are the people impressed not by the giant triumph built near the forum, but by the title of the man for whom it was built, and what a closer social proximity to that man could do for them.  Most striking to me, villa life seemed most of all the domain of femininity, where women became as powerful political operators as their male counterparts, leveraging traditional social norms like child bearing and arranged marriage, social visits and adornments for the family's political and commercial pursuits.  I'm reminded of Catherine Allgor's Parlor Politics, in which the author describes how Washington itself was built by precisely this kind of political domesticity.

This was the place of otium, or leisure, as opposed to negotium, or work and business.  Wealthy Romans from as early as the 2nd century BCE, still 100 years before the fall of the Republic, would build lavish summer homes around the Bay of Naples.  This convention continued once Augustus came to power as Emperor, and for years after until the eruption of Vesuvius in 79 CE, which buried Pompeii and Herculaneum and have since turned them into the stuff of legends.  Surrounding areas also became major trading ports, bringing money into the area from Mediterranean trade in grain from Egypt and other newly acquired Roman lands.  Propelled by so much wealth, the seaside villas serve as fabulous exemplars of what art in this sphere.  It communicates above all the values of those commissioning it, importing it, and buying it, and what they wanted to express by showing it off at home to guests.  These are some of the finest art works at the highest level of craftsmanship available at the time, and as a text is rich with information about the society that possessed and financed them.

Examples of this context abound in Pompeii and the Roman Villa.  Iconography from Egypt and Greece demonstrate the diversity of stylistic influences present among the Roman upper classes, but in a funny way, turning noted statues of gods and nymphs into candle holders and tray bearers.  Mosaics of gardens, dinner parties, and Plato express a desire to create a particular mood.  Paintings of the villas, to be displayed in the homes they represent, communicate a sense of pride and ownership, and capture an unspoiled moment in time, an escape.

So how does one reconcile these depictions with the idea that this was the sphere of real politics?  Certainly it wasn't all black and white, nor can we characterize anyone as a single-minded political machine.  But in the villas, this was leisure time...this was where one showed what he or she thought was beautiful (or thought was supposed to be beautiful), or revered, or special.  I think it's most likely that those who actually enjoyed these leisure activities did have an opportunity to pursue them, and those who really didn't got to act like they did.  I found the figurative depictions of scrolls, writing implements, and scrolls, especially remarkable...this was where one came for his or her own edification--moral improvement, if you will, outside of the dastardly goings-on of the capital city.  Or at least showed you did.  I like the mosaic of Plato with his students at the academy and the bust of Homer most of all with regards to this point.  Most impressive were the consistent portrayals of Dionysos, the Greek god of wine and merrymaking.  This is where you came to cut loose with friends, drink too much wine, have parties and meet people.  Not the politic cocktail reception, but the drinks at the bar after hours.  Rome was a peculiar place when it came to religion--there were any number of gods that one could worship, and the metaphysical realm was hardly an exclusive club.  Almost all of them were accepted into the fold, and as long as one gave proper respect to the gods associated with the state, one could worship whomever he or she wanted...Mithras, Isis, Dionysos.  Whatever.  Leisure time provided ample opportunity for this sort of spiritual pursuit...especially for those committed to our friend Dionysos.

I'm sure at this point, after so much glowing about the material the exhibition features, the reader wonders why I would be so hard on the curating of the exhibition itself.  The first time I visited was before the public opening of the exhibition, reserved for National Gallery of Art donors, which I entered by using my old employer's name.  We started with a lecture by the curator herself, which was an excellent introduction into the premise of the show.  But after it was over, and we entered the exhibition, I was stunned by how...dumb it all was.  The context given in the works' presentation was misguided, favoring the place and the fanciness over the actual historical context.  It left me feeling that I should revere this stuff just because it was Roman and old.  I walked through feeling that the work there had all been done a disservice, treated as marginal Roman art, less interesting than the monumental architecture scattered about Rome or the famous busts at the MFA in Boston or the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and that this was just a hodgepodge of hand me downs that the NGA could manage to cluster together.  This, as the preceding paragraphs suggest, is not in any way the case.  Instead, they played to the crowd, and I found it base.  I visited a second time, thinking that another viewing where I could spend more time with the work would be helpful.  I left irked again, miffed like a scolded child at trying to understand things that were beyond me.

Curating, in my mind, should be a rubric of value.  It should be a guide to says here's why this was valued then, here's why people have valued it through the ages, and then asks, now what value do you find in it?  And although I hate to prove him right (this out of sheer defiant pride), Tyler was right when I first discussed the show with him, and he told me the reason behind the rumors that it was crap...no curating.  This show was the work of an arts scholar, who gave a fantastic lecture but couldn't put it together in a show.  She couldn't find that common vein, instead leaving these valuable pieces in that b.s. wasteland where a lot of fine art and antiquities are placed...for rich people to feel cultured, to revere old stuff just for the sake of being old, for being Roman or Greek.  I imagine curating in the antiquities is a very tough job, trying to present art for an audience for whom that art was not produced, and who ultimately have an exceptionally different worldview that is probably impossible to really understand.  And the vehicle for interfacing between the works and contemporary audiences, the mystique of Pompeii through the centuries, was astoundingly boring, out of place, and made the whole thing feel disjointed.  Specifically, here's what I think they did wrong:

  • Overreached: The curatorial staff should've taken everything out of the show that wasn't explicitly an object of antiquity.  That stuff about the eruption of Vesuvius, the 19th century oil paintings of its eruption, and the attempts to copy those antiquities in later years was awful.  They had plenty there to make an exceptional exhibition, and I think they added the other sections to make it more "current" or "timely".  The last two parts, one of which featuring representations of the explosion of Vesuvius and the excavation, and another a painting by Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema depicting a sculpture garden (displaying alongside it many of the sculptures he painted), were the worst parts of the show, and must have taken a ton of time and money for all the necessary loans.
  • Organized Poorly: All the bells and whistles added to the works to make the garden party theme more believable still didn't save it.  According to the NGA's press release on Pompeii and the Roman Villa, the show is divided into five parts (this is news to me, as it is only vaguely alluded to in the brochure): "Patrons at Home", "Courtyards and Gardens", "Moregine" (the site near Pompeii where the frescos this section displays were discovered), "The Legacy of Greece", and "Rediscovery and Reinvention".  This organization pained me--as a result of it, everything felt mismatched.  Wall text seemed totally out of context or forced, especially in an environment were anything depicting myth got thrown in with "Greek Influence".
  • Missed the Point of a Museum's Existence: I go to a museum to be able to engage as I please with some pieces, skip others, and spend ages staring at just a few.  I know in a visiting exhibition, as opposed to a permanent collection spread, the intent is a little different.  Everything just felt so Disneyland though, and it actually read to me like an academic's first foray into public history or art presentation, as if she felt like it had to be dumbed down to get the masses to appreciate and enjoy it.  I know that the NGA can put on a first rate show that makes you feel smarter for having seen it and considered it.  But in the end, this asked no questions of me...just put several objects together to fit the research that Matusch has been doing for years.  Start with the art, not with the academic paper.

I'm pleased that I got to see all these works, I really am.  But I'm disappointed with how it was presented.  Ultimately, I felt that Pompeii and the Roman Villa just buttressed prevailing images of Greece and Rome, cordoning off these critical times in Western intellectual and cultural history as something we're supposed to learn about and supposed to appreciate, but by the time we're done we just want to go home.  With so few antiquities in Washington, and so much legacy here that draws on precisely that tradition, I gave a sigh reserved from a huge missed opportunity.  I guess there's always Dumbarton Oaks, and Baltimore is just up the road...

1.08.2009

Art and Philosophy in Rome, Part I

When I started this project, and the blog you read now that chronicles its progress, my intent was largely to be able to stick it to people.  To know something about what people were talking about and maybe maybe maybe prove them wrong in conversation, hopefully in front of many others.  I'm a total jerk, and I lack a great deal of self confidence.

In all seriousness, I've intended to give myself something of a cultural appreciation course.  Although I've gotten a great deal out of the methodological aspects associated with research and theory, ultimately this has been an endeavor to know what the hell people are talking about when they mention Degas or the Byzantines...stuff that, despite years and years of school, I just seemed to have missed.  An intended, but not anticipated, side effect of this was to find the chinks in the armor, and to filter the text given to me by the media of my own time through a paradigm of simple facts.  In the case Pompeii and the Roman Villa, on display at the National Gallery of Art until March 22, I saw both sides of this pursuit--seeing and enjoying the physical objects that I had studied only in pictures, and being horribly disappointed with the curating (chinks on all sides...).  So I get a third effect after all, that of beginning to really understand what makes a well curated exhibition and what doesn't.  This series of posts will explore the exhibition in question and the art that it shows, in addition to giving me a much need opportunity to discuss the philosophical climate of Rome at the end of the millennium and through the first century.  Hopefully, I'll manage to paint an adequate enough portrait of the worldview of the Roman ruling and creative classes along the way, and lay some groundwork for Roman literature and rhetoric.  Next, Pompeii and the Roman Villa...

12.18.2008

New Notes on Republican and Early Imperial Roman Art

Taking some time to really consider the Romans relative to their Mediterranean predecessors has revealed some things to me about Rome, art, and the limits of my own method.  Although at first seeming to be a culturally inferior environment for the arts in terms of its sophistication and originality, the art of Rome tells a story wildly different than that which one finds amongst the Greeks.  The tools and methods may be hold-overs from another time, buthe values of the Romans, coupled with an ambitious technical know-how, make for a lot of rich material to think about.  The consideration of that story though has yet again illustrated to me the limitations of the approach I utilize in this project, and  I still struggle against my own dissatisfied internal critic that doesn't want to let me get away with such a general, paradigmatic view of things...

Part one of the Roman art story, and by extension of the society itself, seems to read psychologically raw--competition, alliances, and image.  Art, as I suppose it always has, is a communicative form, but for the Romans it seems like its a medium reserved for a certain kind of message about the subject of the work or the guy who paid for it (usually the same thing).  What I find particularly cool is all the figurative work of people in Roman art and their association with family pedigree, virtue and piety.  I especially love the plethora of busts that abound of men and women, largely because I love seeing representations of the body used for reasons other than their function.  The picture of the "togate male", dating from the late first century BCE, is one of my favorites...he's older, more contemplative, and carries on, both literally and figuratively, the tradition of his ancestral predecessors.  His own seniority and experience are made obvious by his age and the piety he shows by bringing his ancestors into it, and by the simple fact that a sculpture was made of him.  I can't wait to dig more into the concepts of virtue and piety in later posts.

Note here also the talent of the sculptor to make this a stable sculpture...a pedestal to the man's right, and the toga reaching to the floor mask the wooden trusses likely found underneath the marble finish.  Not to mention the details and the somewhat posed position of the man's posture.  Compare to Augustus of Primaporta, who's in a modified contraposto, with the strut masked by the little baby Eros at his right leg (I will dig further into representations of Augustus in later posts.  There's a lot to say on that).

The display of piety is certainly not limited to the ruling classes, either.  See the relief sculpture here, in which to freed and married slaves show homage to their former master in the middle.  Do they treat him as their adopted father, in the absence of real parents?  Do they become part of his household, and show piety to the tradition therein?

Other bits and pieces from Rome's material culture tell a similar story.  Bits and pieces indeed...observe the Ara Pacis Augustae, the Column of Trajan, the Arch of Titus...built to commemorate and glorify the achievements, even the fulfillment of a supernatural destiny, of the emperors of Rome, thus solidifying the form of government and placing the rulers at the levels of the gods.  An old trick, to be sure, and a well used one since then.  In addition, these monumental artifacts don't only tell a story about the society that produced them, they tell a story through the relief sculptures all over them.  A narrative unfolds, telling the major events, the key players, and victories of huge battles in which the emperors emerge victorious and further glorify Rome.

The monumental architecture seems to be just as productive in terms of legitimating the ruling class, building "vulgar" theaters or coliseums to satisfy the masses, or erecting enormous temples to illustrate their commitment to the gods of their society (Roman religion, and Greek to a lesser extent, is something that I still don't feel like I have much of a handle on).  Then again, as in the case of Pompey, the guy just really liked theater, and maybe he just wanted one.  Or maybe those who financed the large temples to the Gods felt they actually owed something to a higher power, or wanted people to be more religious and contemplative.  Certainly I can't speculate so one-sidedly as to everyone's intent.  People just aren't that one-dimensional...are they?  In all these cases, none the less, the innovative use of engineering technologies like arches and concrete made possible structures far greater in scale and stability than had been seen previously.  I still find scale like that impressive.

This "glory of Rome" idea confounds me though.  Is it like the commitment to the city-state and the polis, through participation and democratic process, in some parts of Greece?  Or is it a patriotic ideal, sort of like how people (but certainly not me....er...) believe patriotism works now, getting people to fight and die for the expansion of the empire and the further buttressing of the ruling class that runs it (Republican Patriotism)?  Now we're getting into some fantastically challenging concepts, like honor, piety, virtue, glory, etc.....

Perhaps the glory of Rome, though, is tied into my last point...I think the wealth of Greek statues and Greek copies says as much about Rome if totally original works had as well.  Janson's calls it syncretism, a word I find perfectly fitting.  This was a grand empire, in competition with no one.  Following the age of intense competition throughout the Hellenistic era, when nothing seemed certain and no one's rule seemed safe, to have such a lasting society, in which no force could muster the strength to even make a sizable dent for centuries, must have been remarkable.  Truly, only few had done so up to that time in the world's history, and even since.  Like any empire, they seem to have had few things which were truly theirs, except for their own power and societal structure (enter piety, virtue, tradition...)  The ruling classes had a near mania for antiquities from Greece and, to a lesser extent, Egypt, seems rather fitting as Rome took on the self-proclaimed role of torch bearer of civilization and human productivity.  Funny, though, how civilization works, as Rome and its leaders likened themselves to other civilizations and leaders of the past, as if by further proof of their own important role in the grand design of things.  See, the Pantheon.

10.13.2008

The Etruscans and Emerging Italian Peninsula

Studying the Etruscans has reminded me of another time this project. Prior to the Greeks, I spent a while on the various tribes of Mespotamia and early Mediterranean civilizations (e.g., the Phoenicians, the Minoans…). I feel like I’m doing that again—laying the groundwork for the next shift in power, away from the Aegean to Rome. After all, the Etruscans were just another Italic tribe. I think the Etruscans are known to us in particular because of their well-preserved art and for the conquerors, the up-and-coming, mixed nation tribe centered in the city of Rome.

What’s important for me to note is a lesson I can take with me as I encounter new nations that the Canon encounters in its forward movement (e.g., the Celts, the Cossacks, the Gauls, etc.) These are distinct nations with equally distinct cultures, very much rooted in the realities and circumstances of their respective times and places. With luck, they add a little something of their own to the Canon or become insular enough to escape co-optation and disintegration under foreign rule (see Roma). If unlucky, they fade away into the legend bin of conquered peoples (see Carthage).

The Canon, the list—that culture without a place. It’s a juggernaut. Domination and it have a productive, two-way relationship, and have scratched each others’ backs for millennia.

The Etruscans are among those who managed to add something to the Canon. The Romans carried with them Etruscan sensibilities and religious trappings (by the time the Romans emerged, the Etruscans practiced an amalgam of Greek religion and their own inherited forms of fortune telling and superstition). The art that remains with us gives a glimpse of a society that, although never confederating beyond a series of city-states, had a unique set of cultural practices and history.

Where did they come from, and what was their source? Herodotus suggests Lydia (incredible article here about that), which has some evidence. Indo-European or Phoenician seems equally plausible and a bit more fun to me. They have so much in common with the Greeks of Antiquity and before, with their own regional spin, that there’s something shared there.

In sculpture and decorative arts, we see some differences, but not many. The Etruscans were fantastic metalworkers, and their methods of filigree and granulation still confound scholars. In sculpture, the distance between the cultures is slimmer, although important differences represent the enormous impact that available materials can have on art. Compare these statues:


Similar form, but more gesture in the Etruscan. Whereas the Greeks used marble for sculpture, the Etruscans used terra cotta, a material that allowed for much greater experimentation with movement and creating detail in faces. Many works also show the same Orientalizing and Egyptian influence seen in the Greeks as well.

Despite these similarities, I have to ask myself, what did they add? Therein do I get the real perspective on the Etruscans. It seems likely to me that, at least as far as art is concerned, the Etruscans and Greeks of antiquity shared the same source material, the product most probably of significant cultural sharing as a result of trade networks. But as much as I like to read into the text that aesthetics represent, ultimately I think these are just fashionable stylings, stretched out over centuries. The Greeks themselves didn’t really create anything original until the 5th century, and that work was influenced by a major shift in how artisans thought about their work—an artistic commitment rooted in new ideas about the world. I doubt few of the values of the Greeks and Etruscans had much in common at all. As for the transmission of ideas were concerned, the Etruscans and other Italic people were their own men and women with their own assumptions and beliefs. They shared a vehicle of expression with the Greeks, and that’s all. Those contributed to the formation of the Roman people, not the aesthetic sensibility alone. And I’ll just have to see what that really means when I get on with the Romans themselves.

One thing I can peg now on an Etruscan to Roman link. They gave them the arch:


And the Romans ran with that just fine.