Showing posts with label Mediterranean. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mediterranean. Show all posts

8.31.2007

Lyrics, Born


Not to get too live journal for you, but the ancient Greek perspective inspires a lot of personal reflection for me. This is unquestionably a good thing. Understanding mathematics and music from the ancient Greek point of view has been one of the most challenging and provocative educational experiences that I’ve had for a long time. As a result, I think I have enough material to really make a go of writing a serious piece, an essay on the overlap between Greek logic and my own worldview, and my child-size obsession with learning more. So no post on math, music, and Pythagoras quite yet—that one will take a little work.

This post picks up where I left off with Homer and the oral tradition, and discusses Greek lyric poetry, or verse sung with the accompaniment of the lyre. I focus on two of the most famed lyric poets as identified by Elizabeth Vandiver in Great Authors—Sappho of Lesbos and Pindar of Thebes. I begin by noting a realization on my part—although our knowledge of and familiarity with these famed writers and artists comes via written text, oral communication dominated for centuries. The bard in Greek society seems to me to be one of the primary transmitters of text, and my exploration of lyric poetry stirred me to more fully appreciate this. Furthermore, although I had already learned that Homer’s works had resulted from centuries of oral tradition, I never really considered it with regards to performance. It also didn’t occur to me that even the longest compositions, like the Iliad, surely lived on in the repertoires of the bards of the region for centuries beyond their transcription.

With such a variety of material in the Greek catalog and such an incredible amount to memorize, I can also speculate that a bard’s value derived largely from his repertoire and his performing ability. The categories assigned to parts of this catalog fascinate me…different meters, lengths, instruments, number of singers and even choreography. I think that in addition to the values communicated in the words, one can learn a great deal about culture through the adherence to certain conventions and traditions in the form and content of verse. The dactylic hexameter common among guys like Homer, Thucydides, and Herodotus (I should note that, interestingly, this reference to meter specifies the syllable length, not emphasis), the presence of a flute or a lyre, and whether or not the piece as sung (either by the bard or by a choir), was largely a function of the occasion or setting for which the writer produced the work. The idea that minimum standards for the use of words at all intrigues me. It seems to fit well with the Greek penchant for categorization and order, especially when music was involved.

Speaking of which, the most famous of the poets who wrote poetry for the lyre was Sappho. She surely wrote for small and large events, for solo performers and for choirs, and with varying content. However, she was best known for her very personal written for and performed in intimate settings. Originating from the isle of Lesbos, she earned the nickname of “Lesbian,” as in “Texan or “Spaniard.” The later association between this nickname and feminine homosexuality springs from her reputed involvement in symposium-type orgies and a body of her verse that makes specific reference to erotic feelings for women. I only note this because it brings to light the issue of “ego,” as Vandiver calls it. Does the writer always write as themselves, or as another character expressing emotion and desire different than their own? One must note that given the bard tradition, Sappho very likely wrote not only for others to perform, but for others to hear. As a result, she may have written to cater to a general public whose tastes were largely dominated by masculine desires and points of view. Then again, she may have not. But in the case of the former, doesn’t one see that many of the values communicated in the text here in from other writers expresses the male’s needs, desires, and ideas of beauty? Either way, I’m beginning to see some solid linkages in my network—what little I know of Sappho can add to the list—overwhelming desire for another, and divinely inspired love. Only one work of Sappho’s survives, the “Hymn to Aphrodite.” It’s on my list.

Pindar is best known for lyric poetry performed by choirs at large events glorifying one thing or another. Most commonly he composed odes to the victors of the Olympics and other regional games of similar scale. Customarily, these verses referred to mythological stories, deities and heroes, and related the subject event to timeless truths of human life. The combination of the event and victor’s description with these traditional and philosophical ideas gives the moment a timeless quality, thus immortalizing the winner himself. The presence of this theme in these verses ties Pindar to Homer, and to even earlier texts—the lyricist echoes the Iliad and Gilgamesh by describing a human impulse to pursue immortality through struggle and victory. Considering Pindar as I did Sappho, though, I feel compelled to look critically at the author and at “ego.” Pindar worked on commission for his works…and I can’t imagine that he personally felt any athlete about which he wrote resembled Heracles in his physical prowess. He wrote for the satisfaction of the client, and subsequently may have revealed how common the Homeric morality was. Either way, a collection of Pindar’s victory odes survives—I add them to my list.

The lyric poets, the ancient Greeks, and source analysis in general challenged me to think a little more than I expected. That’s largely because I’m very cocky. Regardless, I considered several things a little more closely or for the first time entirely: elements of authorship such as ego and audience, continuing themes like the Homeric value system, the oral tradition, and levels of text associated with any work. On that note, I close with both the painfully obvious and a couple of new questions that I need to consider. The first rule a history student learns (but few actually absorb/apply) is that the best a historian can hope for when making conclusions about an event or a person is to say “It might…” or “it is probable that…” Ideas only remain within or exit from the realm of possibility following primary source analysis. Thus, Pindar tells us only what the Greeks could have believed and appreciated, at least on an acknowledged, public level. Lastly, an appreciation of poetry relies so much upon reading it in order to hear its rhythm and natural flow that only a few perfect words carefully arranged can provide. Not having read the poems, and not even speaking the language in which they’re written (yet) prevents me from doing this. But I can attempt to understand the conventions and traditions into which these works fit. Poetry has brought this to light, and has applied to Homer as well. One can track stated themes and metaphysical assumptions present in distinct texts. But what can we say about culture after studying the forms of verse and the intent of their authors? This is real subtext, and this is the good stuff. Help me out if you can. The Tragedians and Dionysus next time…

8.03.2007

Homer, The First


This post adds the first texts to my list of primary sources. These represent the first loci in the network, and the first visible destinations on the map. The works attributed to the bard Homer, the Iliad and the Odyssey, serve as fitting firsts.


To our modern sensibilities, it seems clear why the Iliad and the Odyssey made the list. But let us assume nothing. Because in the historical context wherein Homer’s works had the most impact, the Iliad and Odyssey had far greater importance then we can truly understand. To fully absorb this, one must realize (both Bertrand Russell in the History of Western Philosophy and Prof. Elizabeth Vandiver, lecturer on these works in my lecture series, note this point) that these texts had already lived a long life by the time they reached written form. Centuries of oral tradition produced the stories contained in the Iliad and the Odyssey. Furthermore, these tales delivered by bards served as a cultural cornerstone, and once laid out as text they served as the models for language and morality, and communicated the finer points of the Greeks’ history and even religion. Subsequently, those writing and learning during the era of these works’ prevalence absorbed the lessons of these cultural transmitters, and transmitted it themselves.


But it raises an important point—if this is text, whose source integrity I accept despite its long legacy as an exclusively oral text, then do I accept the Old and New Testament as part of the Western Canon, simply for their impact? If I’ve already accepted the Old Testament as a work of literature, and even discussed its nature as a source, and its enormous impact as a transmitter of values which were not just present, but fundamental to the Western tradition, then why not? Would that necessarily open the door to other works which began as an oral tradition then written down, with an clearly observed impact? noted by the surveys I read? This would necessitate reading works in languages that I cannot possibly learn adequately, or, to admit frankly, wish to learn for a variety of reasons (Old Testament-Hebrew, Beowulf-who knows). These are questions I have to consider. Not only will it require some editorial decisions on my part, but some judgements on the nature of this project. You’ll hear back on it soon.


Thematically, the Iliad and Odyssey possess many similarities with the ancient literature I've already studied. I mean, the Homeric texts talk about events in ancient cultures, right? So we see the Myceneans living in the militaristic palaces, and see the attitudes that inspired their construction, or vice-versa. In addition, its very stories have come to define the word epic—thus, we see the influence of Homer on a couple levels. Here, though, I discuss themes.

Prof. Vandiver, who is a professor of classics and also lectures on the Iliad in another Teaching Company collection based only on that book, gushes with little reservation on the themes of the Iliad and the Odyssey and its literary value (not a judgement of her on my part…her personalization of the lecture makes sometimes boring dialogue a type of exciting). This may, I believe, add some sentimentality and subsequently some unnecessary drama to the connections she makes. Having made this caveat, her logical arguments in presenting these themes are compelling. I note this because she becomes especially passionate in expressing the humanity of it all—Achilles’ obsession with death (and as Prof. argues, momentary disaffiliation with life), Odysseus’ story as, fundamentally, the events that ensue because at the near-beginning of the story. Trapped on Calypso's island after the events described in later books (a bit of a chronological mix in the narrative), where he has the option to lived as a god forever with his hostess. Instead, he chooses mortality and the return to the life he left. He chooses to be Odysseus, thus framing nicely the sorrow and loss which his life (years of longing from his home and family, the loss of his companions, etc.), and by extension all mortality, entails. The supposed point in all this seems to be that although filled with pain, the human condition also comprises great joy, or at least feeling. It has a sense of urgency and achievement which an immortal can’t feel. On the subject of immortality, the Iliad contains the interesting themes of "Time" (tee-may) and "Kleos"—objects or indications of one’s honor and a legacy that outlives him after death, respectively. She notes that in the absence of a comforting vision of the afterlife, "Kleos" is all that one has (achieved seemingly through the collection of "Time"). This certainly seems to show parallels with Gilgamesh, who settles on his walls as a form of immortality. But what do these themes mean? And I wonder what connection they really have to the Greek understanding, or even questioning, of the human condition.


Those are at the very least some salient component parts, which hopefully I can bring with me to the sources that come—and maybe the questions asked are the most consistently reappearing themes in the network. But I wonder…am I proving something? Is this a thesis I defend at all? How would I respond to a challenge or evidence of logical weakness? All that being said, it seems likely to me that I’m not proving anything at all, but uncovering, collecting, and connecting together points in a data set. I’ve certainly done a fair bit to define the parameters of my domain—which continue to change. Will I use this data to try to make conclusions? i.e., will I find answers at all? At present I’m happy with exploration.

7.18.2007

"Seen me here?"


I can write a lot more in discussing the ancient Mediterranean civilizations that predate the Greeks, and a great many more things to try to transition into my project as I’ve envisioned it. But those things are drunk. They wobble. You wouldn’t enjoy the pleasure. I note here some observations and a question or two. But it hesitates.

I noted the shape of a bull’s horns featured prevalently in Minoan art. I focused especially on the deliberate representations of the bull’s head (also see the bull lyre of Mesopotamia) and bulls in conjunction with spectacle and ritual. One work in particular, the "Bull Leaping" Fresco, evoked themes I’d encountered in the cultures of other civilizations—male fertility, superiority, the conflict between control and nature, and ritual practice.

But that fresco also really dicked me over, and here’s why. I studied this fresco and its themes in conjunction with the first chapter of History of Western Philosophy. I wound this art too closely with others’ assumption that the Greeks represented a shift, and suddenly my pseudo-theories began. A wave of new questions hamstrung me entirely, and I rethought my project in reference to a new paradigm of self-awareness, the primal self, and the text of our perception. Here it was, this apparently epic moment in history which I had begun to study! This was the gateway to the West itself! The moment when civilization sprang forth from barbarity!….I will meet…I can…Iwillunderstandthisjoyousmagicalmiracle…affiliationsfadeandtheindividualfinally
beginstoutilizehispotential…andspiritualityandthoughtindepend...I will…

…stop trying to create an entire metaphysics and single concept of the “Western World” out of, like, three data points. Bottom line, I learned what I intended to learn in this preface to my real project—a cursory knowledge of the civilizations predating and influencing the network I discover so I can better understand and appreciate common themes and allusions. And I know now what I knew before, prior to forgetting it on a tremendous scale in an undergraduate glimmer of unsubstantiated unifying theories…

The idea of the West is just that—an idea. This project explores cultural works, which can exist as words on a page, or movements, or sculpted rock. But we link these works, we create culture, arbitrarily. “The West” connects these works in a certain way…it’s a certain network, it’s certain linkages, which could be unhinged and reconnected in entirely different ways. Why have they connected this way? Why do we have “a West”? I could never do such a discussion justice here. But I can do what I set out to do—to methodically explore, in text and in person, the Western Tradition. I think that’s ambitious enough. So I begin here, and I will traverse it. But first I have to map it. I will define, for myself, an all-encompassing Western Tradition.