Showing posts with label Plotinus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Plotinus. Show all posts

2.07.2010

And without further adieu...


And so on a Saturday night, when I should be out and about Buenos Aires, I'm here, with you. Seems like no better time and place to finish what I started, or at least, end this stage. What began as a chronicle of an escapism has since grown into a full fledged passion, so to write my final post of this particular blog signifies only that the project still progresses, just transforming. Give me a few months of chrysalis time, as I'm having to learn a thing or two, things I never intended to have to know, but now take up most of my time in learning. In the meantime, here we are; at the beginning of the end for the Romans, and the end of the beginning for the Christians. And quite interestingly, I still linger on a philosopher of the same period, the third century CE, little thought of nowadays: Plotinus, the Neo-Platonist—contemporary of Origen, and author of the Enneads. He, along with a few others like Ovid, Praxiteles and Bertrand Russell himself, have become my friends. Their thoughts stay with me, and have helped me to form my own (as good friends have a tendency to do). I certainly never expected such a deep friendship with these men in particular, but I suppose friendships have that tendency as well.

In my other chapter, the one during which I started this blog, I ran a little coffeehouse. While working behind the counter there one day a few years ago, an elderly Italian man and I began a joking conversation about the actual divinity of the Divine brand chocolate bars which I sold next to the cash register. Having just read a bit about the early Greek philosophers of the Italian peninsula and the Plato, I think I surprised him a little by paraphrasing those cats in constructing a metric for divinity, and even knowing who the hell Parmenides was. Flash forward a few months, I'm editing newsletters about Plotinus for the spiritual fellowship he runs in New York City, a group devoted the concepts shared by Plato and the neo-Platonists (like Plotinus), several Indian scholars, etc.

You see, the work of Plotinus had a heap ton of antecedents, like Pythagoras and Plato, and some eery parallels with a group of yoga-practicing philosophers a hop, skip, and jump east in what today we call India. I certainly could spend my fair share of time reflecting on the probability of real life connections (and even hard anthropological and linguistic evidence that suggests it) between the Dionysian cults, Orphic mystery schools, and certain strains of philosophy originating in South Asia and Iran. We shan't, though, dwell on that here. Relative to the project at hand, I take more pleasure in noting a few particulars in the strain of thinking I think they all share, as it would have a tremendous impact on the thinking that still tenaciously lingers among us today.

I could never do justice to paraphrasing Plotinus, nor would I dare to try in any serious way. Suffice it to say that many call Plotinus's teacher, Ammonius Saccas, the first neo-Platonist, and like Plato they had concluded that our senses deceive us. That which we feel and experience on a physical level, that which we believe to be true based on that which we perceive, is not the whole story. It is, in fact, flawed, whereas the world we think, though the perfection of mathematics and forms, is real. The rest is just a copy. Although we can perceive the real, thought world from hints all around us, it is through logic alone that we truly blaze a trail toward the root source of truth. That truth cannot be defined, but gives truth to all other things. It's the idea without source, the logos of this world. Jesus, I go bananas over that kind of talk.

Speaking of Jesus, I won't go as far as to say this was mainstream thinking, by any means, but as soon as the process of Hellenization got its claws into a recently-not-Jewish Christianity, Greek logical styles and a newly developing Christian theology became fast friends, which we see as early as the Gospel John. John is by far the most mystical of the four gospels, and even refers to God as “logos.” It wasn't much of a leap, after all...once the mythological groundwork had been laid and the lines had been drawn between believers and non-believers, the thinking set among the Christian crowd began to hash out the theology for the relatively new religion. Why? Not sure. My guess is that they wanted to develop a consistent world view, ethics, and morality, based on the death of Jesus, his relationships to God, and to a lesser extent his teachings. What we're looking at, then, is a lot of conditional statements, like “if Jesus is God's son, and Jesus came to save man by dying for him, then...” [enter here 1700 years of more discussion pretty much all based on that]. But these were the first guys to hash this stuff out, and they became known as the church fathers, among them a contemporary and fellow alumnus of Ammonius Saccas, Origen (they'll all go on the list). Frankly, I don't think it's much of a leap to connect Greek style philosophizing with Judeo-Christian religion, especially as far as souls and God are concerned, so I'm hardly surprised at how deeply rooted Christian mysticism is in Greek logic.

However, we can't all be mystics, and hashing out the particulars of an entire religion didn't occur without a fair number of disagreements. What I can't fully wrap my head around is the drive for orthodoxy. I can see why at the beginning the presentation of a clear message was so important. By the 200's, though, creating a Catholic orthodoxy seemed of vital importance to a lot of extremely smart people. I suppose there's some measure of brand management involved, but I think Russell says it best, when he says in the History of Western Philosophy, “The separatist movements in themselves are not surprising, but it is curious that they should have been associated with very subtle and obstruse theological questions.” And separatist movements there were, both within the orthodoxy and entirely outside of it. Gnosticism, a very mystic and very anti-Jewish Christian sect, had at its basis on a separate creation story to validate the “real world is fake” concept. Manichaeism, similar to Gnosticism but drawing more on Zoroastrian traditions, had split off in a manner similar to Gnosticism in that they had separate bishops in certain cities apart from the Catholic ones (although it was not uncommon for spiritual leaders to have leanings one way or another). More importantly, both of these schools had their fair share of adherents.

Within the church, disagreements arose among those fully within the fold on the subject, like whether God was actually higher than Jesus or if they were equal. That matter in particular led to the development of a school called Aryanism (who believed that God was higher), which will play a much greater role later in our story. But for now, let's focus on the fact that despite these disagreements, these thinkers used similar vocabulary, similar units of analysis (soul, body, relative value), and similar methodology by which they developed logical streams of thought, which alone indicates to me that they were all dealing with one another on very Hellenic terms.

I think certainly the circumstances of the third century within the Roman empire made all of these religions relevant to people of all classes. Following the death of the emperor Commodus, the son of the “last of the five good emperors” Marcus Aurelius, Rome began a decline in its fortunes from which it never fully recovered. Although experiencing a brief respite under the Severan dynasty, the office of emperor changed hands constantly, as the murder of one would lead to yet another conflict over his successor. This time, however, the path to succession was hardly clear, and either generals would lay claim to the title or ensure that the highest bidder took the throne. Meanwhile, the the northern and eastern borders had started to crumble, with incursions by Celts, Germanic tribes, Parthians, and Persians. Efficiency and effectiveness of the military crumbled without strong leadership in the top-down Roman system, and resources were stretched. The cornerstone of Roman commerce, its expansive network of secure trade routes, began to buckle at the weight of widespread banditry. Rather than risk it in the poorer and unstable cities, many of the richest in the western empire fled to country estates and stayed there. More wealth stayed in the resource rich eastern empire, causing further disequilibrium. In order to combat these failures in governance, the emperor Diocletian divided the empire into four administrative regions in 286 CE, in a move that was as much a political power sharing agreement as anything. The official art of the period tries to communicate a message of unity among the emperors, but I guess we know how that turned out.


Much as religion and superstition had seen a rise during the period after Alexander's death and the wars between his generals, religion saw a major upswing in the third century CE as well. Instability and uncertainty about the future has a pretty big effect on people, and I'm sure that rewards guaranteed in another kingdom beyond this one had a pretty strong attraction. Jesus is often seen in art as a healer, and a miracle worker, even a magician. Christianity, although going into and out of periods of systematic repression on government orders, began to reach critical mass numbers. What was once a fringe movement had become, essentially, the only organized political force among the populace. Christians held political office (they were some of the few who could read), and their numbers among the poor had overwhelmed the empire's efforts to suppress its growth.

So when Constantine need a victory in battle, a part of his larger (and ultimately successful) effort to reunite the empire under one emperor, he raised the Christian flag. His army, mostly Christians, answered the call. No, Christianity did not become the state religion (that would happen later under Theodoseus), only the favored one, and the recipient of a great deal of money from the state (especially in the new administrative capital of the empire, Constantinople). Nor did Christianity acquire a central leadership until many years later.

However, orthodoxy rears its head again. Constantine demanded that the Christians settle their theological differences and at the Council of Nicea, they (kind of) did, at least as far as God=Jesus=Spirit is concerned. However, bishops in various regions chaffed at the idea of receiving orders and doctrine from central church leadership in Rome—many theological differences followed regional lines, and some bishops had greater influence in their corner of the empire based on their positions on theological matters. These divides would persist for centuries. In demanding orthodoxy, Constantine made the Christian religion a technology of state power. By controlling the ideas and establishing a mainstream, one takes possession of the most important and useful tool for control.

As I conclude, that's really been the theme, hasn't it. At least, that's how I've seen it and written it. Control, power, values. In everything there is an order, and aesthetics and semiotics themselves create and destroy institutions. Understand what we consider beauty, consonance, and even the good, (and who's paying for it) and we discover more about values, human organization, communication, and the means of domination itself.

In the next couple of weeks I'll fully update the list up to about everything I've studied up until now. Then it's onto writing the proposal for 2.0, and a link to the new website which will initially have only the project proposal, but hopefully by September 2010 will be up and running. For now, though, we close antiquity, and a very, very long prelude. Maybe I'll even make “Western Mysticism” an “interest” on my Facebook profile. Three years later, I'm still working on this, more passionately then ever, and I'll post the link to the new site as soon as the proposal is up. Until then, adieu.