
This post adds the first texts to my list of primary sources. These represent the first loci in the network, and the first visible destinations on the map. The works attributed to the bard Homer, the Iliad and the Odyssey, serve as fitting firsts.
To our modern sensibilities, it seems clear why the Iliad and the Odyssey made the list. But let us assume nothing. Because in the historical context wherein Homer’s works had the most impact, the Iliad and Odyssey had far greater importance then we can truly understand. To fully absorb this, one must realize (both Bertrand Russell in the History of Western Philosophy and Prof. Elizabeth Vandiver, lecturer on these works in my lecture series, note this point) that these texts had already lived a long life by the time they reached written form. Centuries of oral tradition produced the stories contained in the Iliad and the Odyssey. Furthermore, these tales delivered by bards served as a cultural cornerstone, and once laid out as text they served as the models for language and morality, and communicated the finer points of the Greeks’ history and even religion. Subsequently, those writing and learning during the era of these works’ prevalence absorbed the lessons of these cultural transmitters, and transmitted it themselves.
But it raises an important point—if this is text, whose source integrity I accept despite its long legacy as an exclusively oral text, then do I accept the Old and New Testament as part of the Western Canon, simply for their impact? If I’ve already accepted the Old Testament as a work of literature, and even discussed its nature as a source, and its enormous impact as a transmitter of values which were not just present, but fundamental to the Western tradition, then why not? Would that necessarily open the door to other works which began as an oral tradition then written down, with an clearly observed impact? noted by the surveys I read? This would necessitate reading works in languages that I cannot possibly learn adequately, or, to admit frankly, wish to learn for a variety of reasons (Old Testament-Hebrew, Beowulf-who knows). These are questions I have to consider. Not only will it require some editorial decisions on my part, but some judgements on the nature of this project. You’ll hear back on it soon.
Thematically, the Iliad and Odyssey possess many similarities with the ancient literature I've already studied. I mean, the Homeric texts talk about events in ancient cultures, right? So we see the Myceneans living in the militaristic palaces, and see the attitudes that inspired their construction, or vice-versa. In addition, its very stories have come to define the word epic—thus, we see the influence of Homer on a couple levels. Here, though, I discuss themes.
Prof. Vandiver, who is a professor of classics and also lectures on the Iliad in another Teaching Company collection based only on that book, gushes with little reservation on the themes of the Iliad and the Odyssey and its literary value (not a judgement of her on my part…her personalization of the lecture makes sometimes boring dialogue a type of exciting). This may, I believe, add some sentimentality and subsequently some unnecessary drama to the connections she makes. Having made this caveat, her logical arguments in presenting these themes are compelling. I note this because she becomes especially passionate in expressing the humanity of it all—Achilles’ obsession with death (and as Prof. argues, momentary disaffiliation with life), Odysseus’ story as, fundamentally, the events that ensue because at the near-beginning of the story. Trapped on Calypso's island after the events described in later books (a bit of a chronological mix in the narrative), where he has the option to lived as a god forever with his hostess. Instead, he chooses mortality and the return to the life he left. He chooses to be Odysseus, thus framing nicely the sorrow and loss which his life (years of longing from his home and family, the loss of his companions, etc.), and by extension all mortality, entails. The supposed point in all this seems to be that although filled with pain, the human condition also comprises great joy, or at least feeling. It has a sense of urgency and achievement which an immortal can’t feel. On the subject of immortality, the Iliad contains the interesting themes of "Time" (tee-may) and "Kleos"—objects or indications of one’s honor and a legacy that outlives him after death, respectively. She notes that in the absence of a comforting vision of the afterlife, "Kleos" is all that one has (achieved seemingly through the collection of "Time"). This certainly seems to show parallels with Gilgamesh, who settles on his walls as a form of immortality. But what do these themes mean? And I wonder what connection they really have to the Greek understanding, or even questioning, of the human condition.
Those are at the very least some salient component parts, which hopefully I can bring with me to the sources that come—and maybe the questions asked are the most consistently reappearing themes in the network. But I wonder…am I proving something? Is this a thesis I defend at all? How would I respond to a challenge or evidence of logical weakness? All that being said, it seems likely to me that I’m not proving anything at all, but uncovering, collecting, and connecting together points in a data set. I’ve certainly done a fair bit to define the parameters of my domain—which continue to change. Will I use this data to try to make conclusions? i.e., will I find answers at all? At present I’m happy with exploration.
2 comments:
1. It seems to me that even if the "loci" of your "datum set" are not arranged linearly, to speak of an event/text/etc as a "locus" is to organize it on a plane, establishing its significance not of its own accord (as if such a feat was possible) but vis-a-vis the relative positions of surrounding points and according to its distinction in absolute space; therefore, I think that your approach is not necessarily exempt from the same ambiguities that plague a progressive or otherwise linear approach to history, due to the fact that it implicitly shares the same plane, albeit an invisible one. In other words, I think that your approach would necessarily (or perhaps not necessarily, I'm not sure) rest on a similar metaphysical grounding, and to distance your own approach from a linear one would require a greater attention to the question of a metaphysical grounding.
2. I cannot help but read into your parenthetical remark on Vandiver's lecture series: "her personalization of the lecture makes sometimes boring dialogue a type of exciting". How and why is it that you would find sections of the Homeric texts "boring"? I cannot imagine that any oral tradition would preserve superfluous or boring lines of poetry so there must be a reason that what is now "boring" was once itself "a type of exciting." The question is thus: what can this disparity teach of us our differing worlds and world views? It seems to serve as strong evidence against what Vico calls "the conceit of scholars" (i.e. to think that a particular way of thinking is universal). And this relates to point 1 above because it prompts prior questions: what middle term is common between the two extremes and what grounds them both in the experience of mankind?
(or perhaps you meant her dialogue and not the Homeric dialogue...)
3. Have you read the Walter Berkert book yet? I feel that there are many salient connections to be made with the Homeric texts (in other words, connecting the archeology with the primary source materials).
Your attention to arrangement strikes me as coincidental—I have spent a lot of “think time” focusing on the subject of valuation, and you seem to waltz around an important issue in your own description of my project. The formation of any data set requires parameters, themselves a kind of valuation/subjectivity. This process of forming boundaries and criteria for the data set implies an absolute value assigned to each point in the set. I must—rules are necessary if we are to distinguish these points in some way from the rest of the known world. These rules develop out of our own observations and experiences. Accordingly, we create the metaphysical backdrop necessary for categorization and, subsequently, domain.
You overlook, however, the phenomenom of correlation…influence, time, etc. I do not seek to arrange, order, or discover a trend among the points. From a social scientific standpoint, that would be a purely statistical methodology. What I attempt is a network mapping, which does not rely on variables necessarily, or even on individual/isolated data points (to have referred to the texts I study as such has been a mistake). The unit of analysis is the network itself…and the part I think you haven’t seen is that the linkages, not the texts, constitute the web I form.
With this methodological distinction stated, I think I can adequately and concisely say that instead of forming my own metaphysics or even absolute rules, I do what any good scholar does and steal/rely on the works of other scholars to provide the groundwork for my production of new knowledge/research. In this case, I rely on the work of other scholars to identify the linkages and “loci,” i.e. transmitters and points of conjunction for these linkages. Like studying the roads on the map by observing only the points of conjunction. I can already tell, though, that this spatial mode of thinking will create some conceptual problems down the road.
As for the book, I should read it soon. Lately some ideas have arisen in my reading that warrant a better attempt on my part to understand the religions of Greece. I speak specifically of my latest fascination with the Dionysian religious tradition, its foundations in the ancient world, and its influence on later mysticism. Russell in particular writes frequently of the mystic aspect of philosophy. This commingling manifests itself on a very generally level where the Mesopotamian/Egyptian religious tradition comes into contact with the more Indo-European influences that one sees in the Olympian gods and the Homeric tradition. There seem to be some clear veins becoming more apparent that follow these different lines…speaking of which, I look forward to humoring my interest in the Dionysian legacy by writing a post very soon which synthesizes Pythagoras (who continued the Orphic and Dionysian religions with his own spin), Greek theories of music and harmonics Euripedes, whose extant notated musical score to Orestes. Thanks for the comment, sorry for the long winded response. I’ve had a lot on my mind about this business and I guess you struck a chord. A.
Post a Comment