2.18.2008

A Clarification by Prof. Walker

I've been in touch with Professor Jeffrey Walker, the author of the book on rhetoric I like so much. He's helped out again by clarifying a suspicion that I articulated in my last post when I wrote:

I should note here the philosophical distinctions between Isocrates and Plato, who despite his anti-sophist associations in contemporary attitudes seems to me like something of a sophist himself according to the original usage of the term.

Prof. Walker wrote in an e-mail today his response to this thought:

About Plato as "sophist": yes. Although he, like Isocrates, wanted to
distance himself from the run-of-the-mill sophists by calling what he did "philosophy" (Isocrates, by the way, was the first to use that term), Greeks at that time would have referred to them both as sophists--professional teachers of , which meant both "wisdom" and "skill" (as in the modern phrases, "know-how" and "savoir faire"). There are fifth and fourth century writers who explicitly refer to Socrates as a sophist (Aristophanes and Aeschines), and I have seen later references to the followers of Socrates -- Plato, etc. -- as the "Socratic sophists."

Thanks for looking out, JW.

No comments: