I had heard about this piece from Christina, one of my few commenters, an avid New Yorker reader. But I must say I was underwhelmed. It all felt so...uninspired; the writer, a classicist himself, treats the material with the distance of quaintness. The whole thing just seems like a brief nod, a "oh yes, of course, old Herodotus"...a snicker and a wink, and passing acknowledgments of the broader political and contemporary issues that the history sheds light on. These reflections, though, stuck to cliche crap, and any comments on the actual edition seemed thrown in out of obligation.
The article gave me pause for a little introspection, though, and I should both admit and explore that here. I just read John Berger's Ways of Seeing, and I think that's made a perspective of which I've always embraced resonate a little more: namely, that to acknowledge a work like Herodotus's as important, at least important enough to release a new edition of it, illustrates the power structures that still operate within the Western consciousness. As Berger points out, cultural texts, and more relevantly the Eurocentric practice inherited from the Renaissance of valuing Classical artistic production, for centuries reinforced authority's dominance and the values which kept it in the supreme position. And although one part of me thinks that I play into this, that to laugh off Herodotus as kitsche does not afford some appropriate respect to Herodotus (hence my introspection), I think my distaste for attitude Mendelsohn exhibits goes deeper. He notes at the beginning of his piece that Thucydides always spoke to his generation of classicists a little more, and to drop the History of the Peloponnesian War in conversations regarding contemporary politics of two decades ago was to show one's acumen in Realpolitik. Herodotus seemed to lack that applicability. But to apply the values of these texts at all seems flawed to me. I would have preferred a discussion of how Herodotus influenced centuries of thinkers and ideas, placing Herodotus within a time, and assigning him importance, and noting why this text is important enough to be re-released, because he was important to many thinkers that many still look to for answers (And I should note here that I don't quite know the motivation of the editor of Landmark to rerelease it). Instead, Mendelsohn giggles like a dinner part attendee at the quality of the writing, the tangents, etc., because they don't measure up to contemporary standards. Well, no shit. I'm glad that he's spending his time now on writing about the present through a comfortably firm (and comfortably institutional) paradigm, because I think he displays a real lack of how to value the past: deconstructing how he thinks now.
No comments:
Post a Comment