6.28.2008
Introduction to Order/Disorder
It’s becoming difficult to focus my thinking as I approach a point where I’ll map the network I created over the last year and analyze it in a larger piece which I hope will bring everything together. So in an attempt to tie loose ends I will write two more posts, both entitled Order/Disorder. The first will discuss the rise and importance of order in Greek text, the influence of Pythagoreanism in the arts, and the larger themes of math and music. The second will address philosophical movements like the Cynics and Epicureans and literary moments like New Comedy as confidence in a fundamental system wanes in the most prevalent texts from the later centuries of Greek Antiquity.
Labels:
Ancient Literature,
Greece,
Greek art,
order/disorder,
Pythagoras
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Adam,
I have a request for your next post: could you address the role of order/disorder in Homer, specifically? Because I think it's interesting that whereas in Hesiod's works "Chaos" describes the original state of nature, which must have Order imposed upon it by Gaia, Uranos and their progeny, in Homer there seems to be no mention of "Chaos" (I didn't actually look) and "Oceanus" rather functions as the origin. I speculate that it's related to Homer's exclusive interest in the Olympian gods, and his suppression of the older/chthonic gods (Although Walter Burkert, as I recall in his work on Greek religion, notices that sky and chthonic do not simply correspond to the new and old gods, respectively, but that both the new and the old gods have sky and chthonic features). So, interestingly, Plato admonishes Homer's portrayal of the gods as tumultuous and uncouth, yet Homer's gods get along much better than Hesiod's, or Aeschylus' for that matter. In Homer, moreover, there is little of the skepticism that appears in the Hellenistic philosophers, where there is almost an existential "angst" over the looming threat of an overwhelming disorder.
My question is basically this: do you see a tension of order/disorder in Homer? If not: what circumstances led to Hesiod articulating such an interesting and powerful tension that would remain in the culture for centuries. And if so: how do you see it manifesting itself?
THanks,
Trip
Trip-
I appreciate your comment, and although I wasn't able to address it directly in my post, I tried to at least touch on the idea with my discussion of fate vs. order. Clearly it's not as black and white as a 1500 word article might suggest, but there's certainly something to be said for the conflict between order and fate as opposing paradigms in Greek culture and it's development from early antiquity through the end of the classical period.
With regards to your introduction, I personally use a great deal of caution when using the word "order" relative to people like Homer and Hesiod. Many have attributed the use of the word kosmos itself to Pythagoras as the originator of its usage. I would agree with you that Homer and Hesiod's intentions in their writing are very different--Hesiod is, after all, the fist known usage of the didactic meter and prose style, whereas Homer was likely the one to simply write down an epic poem that had already been in existence for centuries (although the order of this remains unclear. See the Homeric question).
No, I don't see a tension between order and disorder in Homer. I see a tension later on in the use of the the oral history Homer represents (there was likely a whole slew of text that was orally transmitted beyond just the Homeric texts that we have inherited) and the Dionysian/Orphic tradition that Pythagoras took hold of and promoted. Fate is very different than order, and I concur that Homer lacks an existential angst; why? Because, as Snell tells us, the idea of existence and the individual develops and changes in enormous ways over a few centuries.
I would speculate, based on other things I've read on Hesiod's sources, that he's trying to box the oral history into a new way of thinking, to try and make it work. Furthermore, it's important to bear in mind that Hesiod doesn't suggest a direction, simply an origin, and all world cultures seem to possess a creation myth in some form or another. But this should not be mistaken for a teleology. Lastly, I would suggest that the gods do not impose an order per se, but spring like all existence out of the muddy sea of chaos, and a hierarchy based on struggle and conflict emerges. So Hesiod doesn't seem to actually suggest a plane outside of the physical realm and a moral code derived from it as the later philosophers do.
My knowledge of Hesiod, though, is poor, and I write based on the context in which I know him, and the timelines on which I can place him. I hope we can continue this as we flesh out more possibilities for this very important moment in Greek history.
Post a Comment