10.12.2008

Updated List and Cleaning House on the Method

After an on-again-off-again sabbatical from the project, I did some much needed housekeeping, the perfect vehicle for introspective consideration. It encompasses the following:

1) I updated the damn list. Long overdue. It now goes through the Hellenistic period in art, and intentionally leaves out works on or about Hellenistic philosophical schools. Why? Most of the big thinkers didn't actually write anything of their own or their texts don't exist, and their ideas live on through the written accounts of writers under Roman rule. Furthermore, many of these schools had a significant presence in Roman society, in addition to the reaches of the Hellenistic kingdoms. Thus, I feel it best to discuss movements like the Cynics and Stoics in the context of my discussion of Rome, reaching back to the Greeks when necessary and encompassing resonance among the Romans along with it.

2) I feel that some extremely important elements of my list are almost entirely absent from its presentation on the blog: dates and locations. If I am, in fact, trying to create some conceptual network that forms the basis for a historically paradigmatic point of view of intellectual and cultural development in the West, than it's vital that I include an objective point of reference for the loci of the network itself. This will perform some crucial functions, and add an unfortunate, albeit welcome, amount of work.

First, it will create the boundaries in which the thinking can occur, treating number like constraint rather than simply data...e.g., dates and locations will represent the boundaries within which any kind of creative speculation takes place. Factual knowledge and truth are the parameters, ensuring that I'm not saying that Pythagoras influenced Sappho or something (although Ms. Joost-Gaugier and I had an excellent e-mail conversation about what was for her an admitted stretch, and a tool by which she explored the similarities in their respective media of production). That particular example, and the aside I note, forces mention of an important point: when dealing with ancient primary sources, even the dates themselves are in contention (see the Homeric Question in scholarly debate). Even these supposedly "factual" bits and pieces are points of great contention and academic speculation, so I'll have to do a little research and just make a decision based on the research done by others that I find most compelling. This will at least give me a starting point, and open up another avenue for discussion; I just feel like methodologically, I have to take this aspect of research into account.

Second, it will free me up by eliminating some of the reservations I have about stating possibility x or y with regards to the network. Given that my focus is more on the transmission of values and important turning points and reconfigurations in the intellecutal and cultural history of the West, I can speculate a little more freely on the more theoretical aspects of how priorities and values are shared. I care about progression and forward movement, and focus on that (instead of linguistic groupings or technological innovations, as just a couple of examples). Having a little more confidence in who influenced will certainly strengthen some of my thinking on the original substance of my project.

Etruscans next, and I'm ready to go on that. Thanks for reading.

No comments: