12.19.2008

New Milliken Institute Report on Antiquities Market

The Milliken Institute, an economic think tank based in S. California, has just released a report that explores market based options for stemming the illegal trade in antiquities (you can read the report by getting a login in on Milliken's website).

With all the debate about provenance of antiquities in the market, and the looming specter over most dealers of the 1970 UNESCO treaty regulating the trade, you wouldn't think that this would be such a problem.  Meanwhile, the lab report cites an October story in the International Herald Tribune that suggests the antiquities market is number three in the rankings of black markets, after the predictable drug and weapons industries.

So much seems to ride on the political fallout of the export of the antiquities from their home countries, governed in present day by regimes that have little or nothing to do with the civilizations that produced them except for geographic proximity (then again, I'm an American...what the hell do I know about cultural heritage and identity past a couple of hundred years).  It seems to me, though, that often these repatriation efforts on the part of Rome, Greece, and Egypt just serve to take the attention away from the fact that their parliaments and other ruling apparatuses are complete failures (see Italy and the Neapolitan Mafia, Greece's Riots, and the long history of Egypt's battles with radical Islamic sects, made more popular in part by the absence of ineffective governance).  Identity politics are an excellent way to drum up support from an otherwise ineffective body politic, and items get repatriated into museums with no actual cataloging system for their cultural heritage assets or museum's whose construction are a decade behind schedule.

Hence I was thrilled to learn about the U.K.'s Portable Antiquities Scheme, that at least requires documentation of new finds and enters these artifacts into a system, whereby they are offered up to public institutions, and if no buyers are found can be kept or sold by the individual who finds the item.  At least then provenance is tracked for future generations.  And that's where I think many governments fall short...these objects are not your possessions by your good luck of being found within your modern day borders, but are your responsibility to protect.  I think all those involved in the display and monetary benefit of the possession and display of these antiquities should have a financial stake in supporting organizations located in each country of origin, under the stewardship of that country's government.  It seems that the Milliken report has similar ideas.

Under the lab's proposal, written in conjunction with University of Chicago professor and Cultural Policy Center Faculty Director Lawrence Rothfield, institutionalized financial instruments such as long-term leases to foreign museums and exhibitions, partnership financing for new digs, and "archaeological development bonds" would fill the supervisory and financial-incentive void in the present day archaeological world.  The report also cites the Portable Antiquities Scheme as a clever model, and expand the idea into financial instruments that would take on the existing market as well and put it within the sphere of a regulated market.  It's good to see people thinking about this stuff...however, I think that with any business proper accounting and information is critical, and with the technological capacity available through Google Maps (who continue to do a lot of outreach) and other database technology as seen through the PAS, governments need to step up to the plate and take responsibility for maintaining their heritage, not just using it for political ends.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

Right. The dilemma is over whether the state of origin can in fact care and/or properly display the artifacts. No one seems to have a problem with returning art stolen by the Nazis, but what about the Elgin marbles and the Rosetta stone? or all of the loot Napoleon brought back from his campaigns? Does time alone create a property right in the pillager? To me, the argument based on who can care for it has weight, but I sympathize with the home country's desire to hold its patrimony. What's Sharon Waxman's take on this? Alan Choate

A.M. Hasler said...

Sharon Waxman, author of Loot, seems to stay more or less mute on the subject of what belongs to whom, given the subject's complexity. Where she does weigh in is on the matter of perspective. In the case of the Elgin Marbles or the Rosetta Stone, both in the British Museum, or antiquities like the Euphronios Krater at the Getty in L.A., there is little indication given in the pieces' display that there have been centuries of fights over these objects, and that the provenance of these objects is as much a part of their story as the moment in time, that snapshot, when they were first created. She suggests that museums should at least mention in their curation the dispute over the objects' ownership, or some of the screwed up things that it took to get them out of their country of ownership (see: Zodiac Ceiling at the Louvre).

As I mentioned in my post, I don't think this stuff belongs to anyone. I think they're being used by countries in a continuing imperial v. colonial dynamic still extant in the world, and by largely ineffective governments to score some points with their populace (This is Cuno's argument as well in his book, Who Owns Antiquity?. One big evasion of responsibility on everyone's part. Neil MacGregor at the British Museum seems to be getting high marks for his work there to make a "Global Museum", but the question remains why the "encyclopedia" should be in Europe. There's definitely still some latent (or not so latent) superiority still going around that discussions like this continue to fight against.

As for me, I was attracted to the report from the Milliken institute largely because of its focus on new antiquities that enter the market as a result of continued looting. The repatriation efforts are in large part a separate issue entirely from the effort to stop the enormous black market trading in these items that continues unabated and, in fact, promoted as a result of the enormous price tags for these items at auction.