For the last year, I've pursued the rather peculiar endeavor of mapping "The West;" specifically, its intellectual and cultural history. Of course, "The West" is a particularly nebulous term bandied about by imperialists, cultural theorists, and undergraduate sociology students alike and under varying premises. My "project," my preferred manner of reference when discussing my quaint hobby with family and friends, has been as much an exploration of that cloudy definition as a pleasant manner for me to find some kind of intellectual pursuit in my post-college years. And it has served me well...let me count the ways. I think anyone can attest to the satisfaction derived from self-directed learning. Additionally, despite the rushing advance of society towards points unknown (although such points are the stuff of liberal speculation by, well, everyone), confidence when speaking on the West's cultural canon in most circles still garners a little smile and tilt of the head...or at least the gesture of doing so.
Why should something like the Classics, that body of text written by Greek and Roman thinkers from all reaches of the Mediterranean world, still merit such respect? Why do most afford canonical texts with at least polite acknowledgment, regardless of the modern-leaning discourse on the diminishing applicability of such works in contemporary society? That question alone has been as fundamental to my project as any other curious query I might have as to the contributions of the creative producers of texts whose name I hear in conversation or in any contemporary discourse. There's still something pleasant in knowing a thing or two about the subject when society's taste makers flaunt an ivy-league education, and I can't deny that my defiant streak is somewhat sated in a moment of one-upmanship with a member of the cultural elite. Maybe it's my anarchistic, C. Wright Mills-and-Thorsten-Veblen-reading side talking, but affirming that the emperor isn't actually wearing any clothes remains a source of quiet validation for me. Admitted. I note all this not as some outpouring of my own prejudices against the old-money-rich or their nouveau counterpart who try to fake it (because after being revealed as stupid, they are still rich). I suggest instead that the methodology I've chosen to pursue my project has been as important as the facts I've learned. It has been a project of acquiring knowledge, but also of asking questions: Why are the texts that populate the cultural canon valuable? Why do they still receive an approving nod when noted in conversation, as if the speaker had some networking connection that would open doors in today's society, although the object of conversation has been dead for millennia?
Asking these questions has led me to those grand narratives like the History of Western Music and the History of Ballet, Janson's History of Art and Bertrand Russell's History of Western Philosophy. I'm sure any self-respecting academic would decry the cursory treatment of someone like Seneca or the failure to expand upon George Balanchine's aesthetic revivalism. I love them though; crazy about them because I can craft a network of creators--musicians, sculptors, architects, thinkers, playwrights--and track who influenced whom, who defined a particular era in the eyes of one critic or another, and the qualitative characteristic of a particular medium and the hypotheses on its roots relative to the realities of the time. So in the end, it's not some end-all-be-all, but a sculpture I could build, connecting point after point by strands of values and ideas carried all the way from the Fertile Crescent. Of course, we can break it up into critic-created eras, like the Ancient Mediterranean and the Byzantines and the Age of Nationalism for ease of use and convenient transportation. I would title it "A Possible Trajectory of the West." Fitting, I think, because when one considers truth, isn't that all one has: possibility? Given a particular set of data like dates, locations, titles, etc. (which can themselves be either glaringly wrong or still hotly debated...see "The Homeric Question"), narratives offer paradigms that can never be proven true, only false.
It’s the story of a culture’s various, and sometimes competing, priorities that attracts me most of all, regardless of the epistemological limitations that my project may have. They course over time through geographical networks of people from their origins pulsing at creative periods and sometimes blowing up completely. However, in the process I've shot myself in the foot a bit—before my project I had a nihilistic inkling that most of what society, myself included, treasures and holds most high was full of crap. Now I'm positive that they all came from someone's good idea, or from a mechanism for adapting to some antiquated state-of-being. My new existential crisis might be a symptom of an unhealthy self-absorption (although I prefer "inquiry into an aspect of the human condition"), but I don't mind. Still, liberated though I may feel, in applying this socio-historical perspective I created to my own thinking, distilling the stuff that's come from someone else from what is just mine hasn’t left me with a whole lot. Even more distressing is that I've only gotten through the Mediterranean world.
Maybe I'm just experiencing a priority shift. The realization reverberates (and, fittingly, not at all an original one) that pretty much any new idea just reconfigures the thought and action that preceded it. It drags along with it all the values and morals of generations past, like a cross between a Jiminy Cricket on the shoulder and a fear of disappointing your grandparents. Strangely, I still have the will to understand and to do, without regard to novelty. More presently, I still have an impulse to make and finish my network, which checks two important boxes--the unexplainable urge to use my most human trait of logical and critical thought, and to at least figure out the very ends of the network at the time in which I now live. Then at least I'll know what I'm working with, and be the next to reconfigure. A point on someone else's giant network I'll be, through whom the ideas and values of the past have flown and which best represent, or end, or even begin an era as yet unnamed, as yet unimagined. And barring such glory and success, I still have a neat idea for a clever sculpture, complete with a companion essay. I'll add lights to it, and it will be my favorite light fixture (after my authentic, Art-Nouveau Tiffany desk lamp, or course). It will serve brilliantly as a conversation piece when I invite over acquaintances, impressing them with my boundless knowledge of cultural trivia.
10.06.2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
If you ever get home-sick for Homer, check out:
Flesh and Spirit in the Songs of Homer, by Michael Clark, Clarendon Press, 1999.
Imagine Snell's chapter on Homer, except longer and more thorough.
Post a Comment